{
  "generated": "2026-11-21T09:13:41.790Z",
  "wiki": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/",
  "grid": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/grid",
  "thesisPage": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/anabranch/",
  "title": "The Anabranch of Consciousness",
  "subtitle": "Over three million years, human consciousness has progressed through a sequence of transitions. The Anabranch interprets the most recent 12,000 years as two separate streams. If the evolutionary impulse strives toward wholeness, the evidence tested here (critics included) offers a basis for navigating the current transition, from Material Consciousness to Mycelial Consciousness.",
  "intro": [
    "An [anabranch](wiki:glossary/a-e/anabranch) is a stretch of river that leaves the main channel and rejoins it downstream, and this thesis reads the history of human consciousness the same way. The main channel is [Indigenous Knowledge Systems](wiki:glossary/f-l/indigenous-knowledge), the [Golden Thread](wiki:glossary/f-l/golden-thread) that has carried Gaia wisdom through all of human history. At the [Bifurcation](wiki:glossary/a-e/bifurcation), about 12,000 years ago, [Material Consciousness](wiki:glossary/m-s/material-consciousness) branched away from it, rose slowly at first, and then drove our species up the steep part of the [growth curve](wiki:glossary/m-s/s-curve). At the [Confluence](wiki:glossary/a-e/confluence), now beginning, the two streams learn to work side by side in place.",
    "The argument runs in nine steps. Each step names the kind of evidence it rests on. Seven steps draw on the grid, where 55 sources are coded, critics included; T2 and T9, which no grid step tests, are coded directly against their own wording, with their critics."
  ],
  "parts": [
    {
      "id": "P1",
      "title": "Consciousness reaches beyond the body"
    },
    {
      "id": "P2",
      "title": "The universe has a direction"
    },
    {
      "id": "P3",
      "title": "The Anabranch"
    }
  ],
  "steps": [
    {
      "id": "T1",
      "part": "P1",
      "short": "Beyond the body",
      "name": null,
      "connector": null,
      "claim": "Consciousness exists beyond the body.",
      "evidence": "Argument, with testimony",
      "status": "mapped",
      "primary": "H",
      "secondary": [],
      "note": "Drawn from grid step H, consciousness is fundamental. A source can hold that consciousness is fundamental without holding that it exists outside a body, so each position is checked against this wording. Thirty-one sources are now coded directly. James's Human Immortality (1898) argues only that survival is compatible with the brain's role, and Myers's Human Personality (1903) argues that personality survives bodily death. Wilber holds consciousness to be nondual Spirit with no argument for individual survival, and qualifies the step. Chalmers, Deacon, Hoffman, Barfield, Gebser, Varela and colleagues and Medawar say nothing on survival. Seth and Dennett tie experience to the living body. Feinberg and Mallatt, Ginsburg and Jablonka, Jaynes and Lewis-Williams give production accounts that leave nothing beyond it, and Churchland (2013), Lamont (1935) and Paul Edwards's Immortality (1992) argue against survival from the dependence of mind on brain. One position, Laszlo's, is still copied from H.",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/anabranch/t1-consciousness-exists-beyond-the-body",
      "counts": {
        "affirms": 5,
        "qualifies": 9,
        "dissents": 11,
        "silent": 116
      },
      "checked": 31,
      "gridStep": {
        "code": "H",
        "title": "H. Consciousness is fundamental",
        "claim": "Consciousness is a basic feature of reality and is not produced by brains.",
        "connector": "cross-cutting",
        "evidence": "Argument (E3 to E4)",
        "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/steps/h-consciousness-is-fundamental",
        "counts": {
          "affirms": 8,
          "qualifies": 4,
          "dissents": 8,
          "silent": 35
        }
      },
      "secondarySteps": []
    },
    {
      "id": "T2",
      "part": "P1",
      "short": "How information arrives",
      "name": null,
      "connector": "and",
      "claim": "Information arrives in ways that [Material Consciousness](wiki:glossary/m-s/material-consciousness) has not explained.",
      "evidence": "Measured studies (E1), contested by failed replications and critiques, with testimony (E5)",
      "status": "mapped",
      "primary": null,
      "secondary": [],
      "note": "No grid step tests this. Sources are coded on it directly: the experimental record, the cardiac arrest studies and testimony, with their critics. Critics outnumber supporters, fourteen to seven. Hyman (2010) and Rouder and colleagues (2013) answer the ganzfeld meta-analysis. Weiler and Woollacott (2025) call for controlled tests of the claims in The Telepathy Tapes, and Delgado-Ron (2026) replies. Beals, Boynton, Hupp and Vyse answer the podcast in Skeptical Inquirer 50(5), and the Association for Science in Autism Treatment rejects its claims. Danny Whitty, a nonspeaking writer, trusts peers who report telepathy and objects that the podcast harms access to spelling.",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/anabranch/t2-information-arrives",
      "counts": {
        "affirms": 7,
        "qualifies": 7,
        "dissents": 14,
        "silent": 0
      },
      "checked": 28,
      "gridStep": null,
      "secondarySteps": []
    },
    {
      "id": "T3",
      "part": "P1",
      "short": "Brain as filter",
      "name": null,
      "connector": "so",
      "claim": "The human brain filters consciousness from the field and does not produce it. A possible synthesis shows environment, education and enthusiasm (personal interests, passions and desires) shaping what comes through.",
      "evidence": "Theory. The three Es are Michael Haupt's synthesis [MS].",
      "status": "partial",
      "primary": "H",
      "secondary": [],
      "note": "Grid step H covers the claim that brains do not produce consciousness. James's Human Immortality (1898), Bergson's Matter and Memory (1896) and Myers's Human Personality (1903) are the primary filter texts, Huxley's reducing valve (1954) is its best-known modern statement, and Kelly and colleagues (2007) defend the filter model. Kastrup (2019), REBUS, McGilchrist (2021), James's Varieties, Aurobindo, Chalmers and Webb (2023) qualify it; Webb questions how Huxley built the valve from Bergson and Broad. Augustine and Martin (2015), Churchland (2013), Lamont (1935), Paul Edwards's Immortality (1992), Lewis-Williams, Seth, Dennett, Deacon, Feinberg and Mallatt, and Ginsburg and Jablonka hold that brains give rise to consciousness. No critic found so far presses the point that the founders of filter theory gave analogies and no mechanism. Six positions are still copied from H.",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/anabranch/t3-the-brain-filters-consciousness",
      "counts": {
        "affirms": 8,
        "qualifies": 13,
        "dissents": 11,
        "silent": 109
      },
      "checked": 27,
      "gridStep": {
        "code": "H",
        "title": "H. Consciousness is fundamental",
        "claim": "Consciousness is a basic feature of reality and is not produced by brains.",
        "connector": "cross-cutting",
        "evidence": "Argument (E3 to E4)",
        "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/steps/h-consciousness-is-fundamental",
        "counts": {
          "affirms": 8,
          "qualifies": 4,
          "dissents": 8,
          "silent": 35
        }
      },
      "secondarySteps": []
    },
    {
      "id": "T4",
      "part": "P2",
      "short": "Directional striving",
      "name": null,
      "connector": null,
      "claim": "The universe and everything within it strives towards higher expressions of itself. Some call this building complexity. Others call the guiding force God, and others the Evolutionary Impulse.",
      "evidence": "Measured for the rise in complexity; argued for the striving",
      "status": "partial",
      "primary": "B3",
      "secondary": [],
      "note": "Drawn from grid step B3. The rise in complexity is measured (Chaisson) and modelled (Prigogine); both qualify the step, since neither claims that the universe strives. The claim that it has a direction is argued (Teilhard, Aurobindo, Wilber). Nagel (2012) proposes a teleology in nature, and Sober (2012) rejects his argument. Seventeen positions are still copied from B3.",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/anabranch/t4-the-universe-strives",
      "counts": {
        "affirms": 7,
        "qualifies": 11,
        "dissents": 6,
        "silent": 117
      },
      "checked": 8,
      "gridStep": {
        "code": "B3",
        "title": "B3. Complexity has risen over cosmic time; some sources hold that consciousness rides a directional trend",
        "claim": "Measured complexity has risen across cosmic, biological and cultural systems. Some sources go further and hold that consciousness rides a direction in that rise.",
        "connector": "SO (contested)",
        "evidence": "E1 to E3 for the rise in complexity (Chaisson); E4 to E5 for the direction (Teilhard, Aurobindo, Wilber)",
        "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/steps/b3-complexity-has-a-direction",
        "counts": {
          "affirms": 10,
          "qualifies": 6,
          "dissents": 6,
          "silent": 33
        }
      },
      "secondarySteps": []
    },
    {
      "id": "T5",
      "part": "P2",
      "short": "Individual participation",
      "name": null,
      "connector": "and",
      "claim": "Every individual takes part in this process, consciously or unconsciously. Few of us have been taught this.",
      "evidence": "Argument",
      "status": "partial",
      "primary": "B1",
      "secondary": [
        "B2"
      ],
      "note": "Grid step B1, individuals develop through stages, is the nearest coded claim. Taking part in a cosmic process is a stronger claim than developing through stages. Loevinger, Kegan, and Beck and Cowan describe stages of individual development with no cosmic claim, and qualify the step; Tomasello, Siegler, and Fischer and Bidell are silent on it. Berry (1988) and Swimme and Tucker (2011) affirm the step, both read from summaries, and Briggs and Sahtouris qualify it. Montessori's Cosmic Education (1948) and the Big History Project (2011) qualify the claim that we have never been taught this, since each teaches a cosmic story in schools; Conrad (2019) finds the Big History curriculum Eurocentric. Dundes (2005) and Segal (1991) dissent, against Campbell's claim of a hero story shared by every culture. Campbell's own book is not yet coded. Three positions are still copied from B1.",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/anabranch/t5-everyone-takes-part",
      "counts": {
        "affirms": 4,
        "qualifies": 9,
        "dissents": 2,
        "silent": 126
      },
      "checked": 15,
      "gridStep": {
        "code": "B1",
        "title": "B1. Individuals develop through stages",
        "claim": "Adults can move through stages of meaning-making that validated instruments can measure.",
        "evidence": "E1 measured study for the Washington University Sentence Completion Test; thinner for other instruments",
        "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/steps/b1-individuals-develop-through-stages",
        "counts": {
          "affirms": 5,
          "qualifies": 4,
          "dissents": 0,
          "silent": 46
        }
      },
      "secondarySteps": [
        {
          "code": "B2",
          "title": "B2. Culture and person follow parallel sequences",
          "claim": "The cultural sequence and the individual sequence show the same order.",
          "connector": "AND (contested)",
          "evidence": "E4 synthesis",
          "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/steps/b2-culture-and-person-follow-parallel-sequences",
          "counts": {
            "affirms": 3,
            "qualifies": 1,
            "dissents": 1,
            "silent": 50
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "T6",
      "part": "P2",
      "short": "Towards wholeness",
      "name": null,
      "connector": "so",
      "claim": "The universe has a direction, and the overall trend is towards wholeness.",
      "evidence": "Argument and tradition",
      "status": "partial",
      "primary": "C2",
      "secondary": [
        "B3"
      ],
      "note": "Drawn from grid step C2, a new structure is emerging, with B3 for the direction itself. Eleven positions are still copied from C2. Of the sources coded directly, the Ra Material affirms the step, Briggs and Schmachtenberger qualify it, and Donald, Habermas and Ong are silent on it. Daoist scholarship reads the movement of the way as return and transformation with no end named, so Lau's translation of the Daodejing (1963) and Ziporyn's Zhuangzi (2009) qualify the step. Ruse (1996) traces belief in evolutionary progress to cultural ideas of Progress. Gould's Wonderful Life (1989) and Full House (1996), and Butterfield (1931), dissent, against a built-in direction in the history of life and in the writing of history. None of these six works speaks to wholeness as a trend.",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/anabranch/t6-the-trend-is-towards-wholeness",
      "counts": {
        "affirms": 9,
        "qualifies": 6,
        "dissents": 5,
        "silent": 121
      },
      "checked": 12,
      "gridStep": {
        "code": "C2",
        "title": "C2. Some sources hold that a new structure is emerging now",
        "claim": "A transition comparable to the earlier ones is under way.",
        "evidence": "E4 synthesis to E5 testimony",
        "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/steps/c2-a-new-structure-is-emerging",
        "counts": {
          "affirms": 10,
          "qualifies": 3,
          "dissents": 3,
          "silent": 39
        }
      },
      "secondarySteps": [
        {
          "code": "B3",
          "title": "B3. Complexity has risen over cosmic time; some sources hold that consciousness rides a directional trend",
          "claim": "Measured complexity has risen across cosmic, biological and cultural systems. Some sources go further and hold that consciousness rides a direction in that rise.",
          "connector": "SO (contested)",
          "evidence": "E1 to E3 for the rise in complexity (Chaisson); E4 to E5 for the direction (Teilhard, Aurobindo, Wilber)",
          "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/steps/b3-complexity-has-a-direction",
          "counts": {
            "affirms": 10,
            "qualifies": 6,
            "dissents": 6,
            "silent": 33
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "T7",
      "part": "P3",
      "short": "Bifurcation of thought",
      "name": "The Bifurcation",
      "connector": "together",
      "claim": "At the Mythic to Material transition, consciousness split into two streams, as one possible interpretation of the Garden of Eden story tells it. [Indigenous Knowledge Systems](wiki:glossary/f-l/indigenous-knowledge) held Gaia wisdom as the [Golden Thread](wiki:glossary/f-l/golden-thread). [Material Consciousness](wiki:glossary/m-s/material-consciousness) drove the species up the steep part of the S-shaped [Logistic Growth Principle](wiki:glossary/m-s/s-curve).",
      "evidence": "Dated record and argument. The S-curve reading is Michael Haupt's synthesis [MS].",
      "status": "partial",
      "primary": "A3",
      "secondary": [
        "C1"
      ],
      "note": "Drawn from grid step A3, the structure of awareness changed, with C1, earlier structures stay present, for the Golden Thread. Thirty sources are coded directly, three of them silent, and four positions are still copied from A3. No source affirms all three parts. On the split, part (a), Jaynes, Ong, Jaspers, Gebser, Barfield, McGilchrist, Wilber and Briggs describe a transition in mind or culture and speak to no other part, so each qualifies; Block (1981), Street (1984) and Graeber and Wengrow (2021) dispute such a transition. Eisler (1987), Taylor (2005) and Quinn's The Story of B (1996) argue for a break some thousands of years ago, and Trible (1978) reads Eden as a love story gone awry. Eller (2000) disputes the lost partnership age behind such readings, and Barr (1992), Fretheim (1994) and Meyers (2013) read Genesis 2 and 3 without a split in consciousness. On part (b), Wilson (2008), Odora Hoppers (2002) and Deloria (1995) speak of the standing of Indigenous knowledge in their own terms, beside South Africa's Indigenous Knowledge Systems policy (2004). On part (c), Modis (2002) and Smil (2019) fit logistic curves to complexity and to empires. No source read in its text, Briggs's Emerging World (2021) included, ties the steep part of a civilisational S-curve to Material Consciousness; that link is Michael Haupt's synthesis [MS]. Material Consciousness branches at the Bifurcation, with the Neolithic Revolution about 12,000 years ago, and rises slowly while Mythic structures still lead coordination; it drives the steep part of the curve once it comes to lead, which the Major Evolutionary Transitions page dates from the scientific revolution [MS].",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/anabranch/t7-the-bifurcation",
      "counts": {
        "affirms": 0,
        "qualifies": 25,
        "dissents": 6,
        "silent": 110
      },
      "checked": 30,
      "gridStep": {
        "code": "A3",
        "title": "A3. Some sources hold that the steps changed the structure of awareness",
        "claim": "Gebser, Jaynes, Barfield and others argue that space, time and self were experienced differently after each step. Donald, Ong, Mithen and Deacon describe the same steps as changes in cognitive capacity and memory.",
        "connector": "EXPLAINED BY (some sources)",
        "evidence": "E3 theory on evidence to E4 synthesis",
        "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/steps/a3-the-steps-changed-the-structure-of-awareness",
        "counts": {
          "affirms": 9,
          "qualifies": 6,
          "dissents": 2,
          "silent": 38
        }
      },
      "secondarySteps": [
        {
          "code": "C1",
          "title": "C1. Earlier structures stay present",
          "claim": "No structure replaces the ones before it; all are active in everyone now.",
          "evidence": "E3 theory on evidence to E4 synthesis",
          "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/steps/c1-earlier-structures-stay-present",
          "counts": {
            "affirms": 9,
            "qualifies": 6,
            "dissents": 1,
            "silent": 39
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "T8",
      "part": "P3",
      "short": "Where growth slows",
      "name": null,
      "connector": "so",
      "claim": "As we reach the [limits to growth](wiki:sources/meadows-limits-to-growth), where the [S-curve](wiki:glossary/m-s/s-curve) levels off, the individual learns to draw on the [Noosphere](wiki:glossary/m-s/noosphere), the wisdom of the universe, to grow towards wholeness.",
      "evidence": "Argument and tradition",
      "status": "partial",
      "primary": "C3",
      "secondary": [
        "C4"
      ],
      "note": "Drawn from grid step C3, networked collective intelligence, which carries Teilhard's noosphere and Medawar's critique of it. C4 records how the current structure resists. Modis reads the long series of complexity as logistic and Korotayev as hyperbolic, and Smil warns against placing a system on its curve from past fits; no source places the Noosphere at a point on the curve. Vernadsky's essay of 1945, the first English statement of the noosphere, describes a geochemical stage brought about by science and labour, with no curve and no individual drawing on it. Schmachtenberger calls for collective sensemaking with no Noosphere and no curve, and The Limits to Growth (1972) and Tainter (1988) treat limits and collapse with no claim about consciousness; all three qualify the step. Simard, Karst and Yunkaporta are silent on it. Four positions are still copied from C3.",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/anabranch/t8-the-noosphere",
      "counts": {
        "affirms": 2,
        "qualifies": 9,
        "dissents": 2,
        "silent": 128
      },
      "checked": 12,
      "gridStep": {
        "code": "C3",
        "title": "C3. Its proposed sign is networked, collective intelligence",
        "claim": "The new structure shows up as distributed, relational, collective intelligence. \"Mycelial\" names a metaphor for this; fungal network science is evidence about fungi.",
        "connector": "FELT AS",
        "evidence": "E4 synthesis, with contested E1 work on group intelligence",
        "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/steps/c3-networked-collective-intelligence",
        "counts": {
          "affirms": 3,
          "qualifies": 4,
          "dissents": 1,
          "silent": 47
        }
      },
      "secondarySteps": [
        {
          "code": "C4",
          "title": "C4. The current leading structure resists it",
          "claim": "The structure that leads now holds the new one back: Gebser's deficient mental-rational phase, McGilchrist's left-hemisphere emphasis, Kuhn's normal science.",
          "connector": "RESISTED BY",
          "evidence": "E4 synthesis",
          "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/steps/c4-the-current-structure-resists-it",
          "counts": {
            "affirms": 6,
            "qualifies": 2,
            "dissents": 2,
            "silent": 45
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "T9",
      "part": "P3",
      "short": "Place-based wholeness",
      "name": "The Confluence",
      "connector": "pointing towards",
      "claim": "Now the two streams are learning to work side by side, towards place-based wholeness. Bioregionalism is how that looks on the ground.",
      "evidence": "Theory on evidence (E3), with national policy (E2)",
      "status": "partial",
      "primary": null,
      "secondary": [],
      "note": "No grid step tests this. Sources are coded on it directly: work on Two-Eyed Seeing and on bioregionalism, with their critics. It is also the position the BioConomy network writes from. The count is 5 affirms, 5 qualifies and 4 dissents. Odora Hoppers (2002) is the newest affirm: the volume she edited argues for joining indigenous knowledge systems with the sciences through what it calls articulation.",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/anabranch/t9-the-confluence",
      "counts": {
        "affirms": 5,
        "qualifies": 5,
        "dissents": 4,
        "silent": 0
      },
      "checked": 14,
      "gridStep": null,
      "secondarySteps": []
    }
  ],
  "groups": [
    "1. Mind and brain science",
    "2. Philosophy of mind",
    "3. Cognitive archaeology and the history of mind",
    "4. Developmental maps",
    "5. Complexity and cosmic evolution",
    "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
    "7. Metacrisis and the mycelial turn",
    "8. Traditions and testimony",
    "9. Critics of the sequence",
    "10. Anomalous experience research",
    "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
    "12. Growth curves and limits",
    "13. Place and bioregionalism"
  ],
  "sources": [
    {
      "slug": "deacon-1997-the-symbolic-species",
      "title": "The Symbolic Species",
      "author": "Terrence W. Deacon",
      "year": 1997,
      "group": "1. Mind and brain science",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/deacon-1997-the-symbolic-species",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Explains the symbolic mind through the co-evolution of brain and language, and does not discuss consciousness beyond the body.",
          "cite": "The Symbolic Species (1997), as described in reviews; no chapter checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Treats symbolic consciousness as arising from the co-evolution of language and brain.",
          "cite": "The Symbolic Species (1997), final chapters, which end with Darwinian views of consciousness (per Calvin); chapter number not confirmed",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Argues symbols reorganized human cognition, a claim about capacity with no stage sequence of awareness.",
          "cite": "The Symbolic Species (1997), final chapters",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "feinberg-mallatt-2016-ancient-origins",
      "title": "The Ancient Origins of Consciousness",
      "author": "Todd E. Feinberg, Jon M. Mallatt",
      "year": 2016,
      "group": "1. Mind and brain science",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/feinberg-mallatt-2016-ancient-origins",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Holds consciousness to be an emergent product of nervous systems, a production account that leaves nothing beyond the body.",
          "cite": "The Ancient Origins of Consciousness (2016), ch. 10 (inference)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Holds consciousness to be an emergent product of nested neural hierarchies, a production model of the brain.",
          "cite": "The Ancient Origins of Consciousness (2016), ch. 10 'Neurobiological Naturalism: A Consilience'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Treats rising neural complexity as the route to consciousness in some lineages, with no claim of a cosmic trend.",
          "cite": "The Ancient Origins of Consciousness (2016), ch. 10 'Neurobiological Naturalism: A Consilience'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Treats rising neural complexity as the route to consciousness in some lineages, with no claim of a cosmic trend.",
              "cite": "The Ancient Origins of Consciousness (2016), ch. 10 'Neurobiological Naturalism: A Consilience'",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "abstract"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "carhart-harris-friston-2019-rebus",
      "title": "REBUS and the Anarchic Brain: Toward a Unified Model of the Brain Action of Psychedelics",
      "author": "R. L. Carhart-Harris; K. J. Friston",
      "year": 2019,
      "group": "1. Mind and brain science",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1124/pr.118.017160",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/carhart-harris-friston-2019-rebus",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that the brain constrains experience through priors that psychedelics relax, within a naturalistic model of a brain that produces experience.",
          "cite": "Pharmacological Reviews 71(3) (2019), model sections",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "ginsburg-jablonka-2019-sensitive-soul",
      "title": "The Evolution of the Sensitive Soul",
      "author": "Simona Ginsburg, Eva Jablonka",
      "year": 2019,
      "group": "1. Mind and brain science",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/ginsburg-jablonka-2019-sensitive-soul",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Holds consciousness to be an evolved biological mode of being, a production account that leaves nothing beyond the body.",
          "cite": "The Evolution of the Sensitive Soul (2019), Part I, ch. 1 'Goal-Directed Systems: An Evolutionary Approach to Life and Consciousness' (p. 5) and ch. 3 'The Emergentist Consensus: Neurobiological Perspectives' (p. 95) (inference)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Holds consciousness to be an evolved biological mode of being, produced in animals capable of unlimited associative learning.",
          "cite": "The Evolution of the Sensitive Soul (2019), Part I, ch. 1 'Goal-Directed Systems: An Evolutionary Approach to Life and Consciousness' (p. 5) and ch. 3 'The Emergentist Consensus: Neurobiological Perspectives' (p. 95)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Frames the history of mind as transitions in the style of Maynard Smith and Szathmáry, with no fixed end.",
          "cite": "The Evolution of the Sensitive Soul (2019), 'Introduction to Part II: Major Transitions in the Evolution of the Mind' (p. 241)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Frames the history of mind as transitions in the style of Maynard Smith and Szathmáry, with no fixed end.",
              "cite": "The Evolution of the Sensitive Soul (2019), 'Introduction to Part II: Major Transitions in the Evolution of the Mind' (p. 241)",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "abstract"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "seth-2021-being-you",
      "title": "Being You",
      "author": "Anil Seth",
      "year": 2021,
      "group": "1. Mind and brain science",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/seth-2021-being-you",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Holds that when life ends, consciousness ends too.",
          "cite": "Being You (2021), Prologue",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Treats experience as the brain's controlled hallucination within a physicalist frame.",
          "cite": "Being You (2021), pp. 18, 22",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "mcgilchrist-2021-the-matter-with-things",
      "title": "The Matter with Things",
      "author": "Iain McGilchrist",
      "year": 2021,
      "group": "1. Mind and brain science",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/mcgilchrist-2021-the-matter-with-things",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Treats the brain as possibly permissive or transmissive of consciousness, while leaving production open.",
          "cite": "The Matter with Things (2021), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "levin-2022-technological-approach-to-mind-everywhere",
      "title": "Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere: An Experimentally-Grounded Framework for Understanding Diverse Bodies and Minds",
      "author": "Michael Levin",
      "year": 2022,
      "group": "1. Mind and brain science",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.3389/fnsys.2022.768201",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/levin-2022-technological-approach-to-mind-everywhere",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that every known mind is a collective intelligence of agentic parts, at all scales of life, with no claim of a new human stage.",
          "cite": "Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience 16: 768201 (2022), introduction",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "andrews-birch-sebo-2024-new-york-declaration",
      "title": "The New York Declaration on Animal Consciousness",
      "author": "Kristin Andrews, Jonathan Birch, Jeff Sebo et al.",
      "year": 2024,
      "group": "1. Mind and brain science",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://sites.google.com/nyu.edu/nydeclaration/declaration",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/andrews-birch-sebo-2024-new-york-declaration",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "bergson-1896-matter-and-memory",
      "title": "Matter and Memory",
      "author": "Henri Bergson; Nancy Margaret Paul (translator); W. Scott Palmer (translator)",
      "year": 1896,
      "group": "2. Philosophy of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://brocku.ca/MeadProject/Bergson/Bergson_1911b/Bergson_1911_01.html",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/bergson-1896-matter-and-memory",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Holds that the brain selects what enters conscious perception for action and does not produce representation.",
          "cite": "Matter and Memory (1911 trans.), ch. I, 'Of the Selection of Images for Conscious Presentation. What Our Body Means and Does', esp. pp. 19-21 and 30-31",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "james-1898-human-immortality",
      "title": "Human Immortality: Two Supposed Objections to the Doctrine",
      "author": "William James",
      "year": 1898,
      "group": "2. Philosophy of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.religion-online.org/book/human-immortality/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/james-1898-human-immortality",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Argues that survival is compatible with brain dependence and declines to claim that the evidence proves survival.",
          "cite": "Human Immortality (1898), lecture and Preface",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Proposes that the brain may have a permissive or transmissive function, sifting a wider consciousness it does not produce.",
          "cite": "Human Immortality (1898), lecture",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "james-1902-varieties-of-religious-experience",
      "title": "The Varieties of Religious Experience",
      "author": "William James",
      "year": 1902,
      "group": "2. Philosophy of mind",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/james-1902-varieties-of-religious-experience",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Suggests that the subconscious self opens onto a wider consciousness; the filter thesis proper is in Human Immortality (1898).",
          "cite": "The Varieties of Religious Experience (1902), Lecture XX 'Conclusions'; Postscript not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "varela-thompson-rosch-1991-embodied-mind",
      "title": "The Embodied Mind",
      "author": "Francisco J. Varela, Evan Thompson, Eleanor Rosch",
      "year": 1991,
      "group": "2. Philosophy of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/varela-thompson-rosch-1991-embodied-mind",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Joins cognitive science and Buddhist practice in an enactive account of embodied mind, and does not take up survival beyond the body.",
          "cite": "The Embodied Mind (1991), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Takes a middle way that denies both a fixed objective world and a fixed self.",
          "cite": "The Embodied Mind (1991), Part V 'Worlds without Ground', ch. 10 'The Middle Way'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Shows through mindfulness practice that experience can be reorganised by training, a claim about states of mind.",
          "cite": "The Embodied Mind (1991), Part I, ch. 2 'What Do We Mean \"Human Experience\"?', and Part II, ch. 4 'The I of the Storm'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "chalmers-1996-the-conscious-mind",
      "title": "The Conscious Mind",
      "author": "David J. Chalmers",
      "year": 1996,
      "group": "2. Philosophy of mind",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/chalmers-1996-the-conscious-mind",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Does not discuss survival of bodily death.",
          "cite": "The Conscious Mind (1996), chapter summaries for chs 1 to 10 in the author's précis",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Rejects materialism while holding that consciousness depends lawfully on physical organization; offers no filter model.",
          "cite": "The Conscious Mind (1996), ch. 4 'Naturalistic Dualism' and ch. 7 'Absent Qualia, Fading Qualia, Dancing Qualia'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "kelly-2007-irreducible-mind",
      "title": "Irreducible Mind",
      "author": "Edward F. Kelly, Emily Williams Kelly et al.",
      "year": 2007,
      "group": "2. Philosophy of mind",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/kelly-2007-irreducible-mind",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Judges that the evidence tilts toward survival over super-psi explanations.",
          "cite": "Irreducible Mind (2007), ch. 9 'Toward a Psychology for the 21st Century', section 'Post-Mortem Survival', p. 601 ff.; see also ch. 4 'Memory' (Alan Gauld), p. 297",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Defends the Myers and James filter or transmission theory of the brain.",
          "cite": "Irreducible Mind (2007), ch. 2 (Emily Williams Kelly, on Myers) and the final chapter (ch. 9), 'Toward a Psychology for the 21st Century'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "nagel-2012-mind-and-cosmos",
      "title": "Mind and Cosmos: Why the Materialist Neo-Darwinian Conception of Nature Is Almost Certainly False",
      "author": "Thomas Nagel",
      "year": 2012,
      "group": "2. Philosophy of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/nagel-2012-mind-and-cosmos",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Proposes natural teleological principles that make the rise of life and consciousness likely, without a designer.",
          "cite": "Mind and Cosmos (2012), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "churchland-2013-touching-a-nerve",
      "title": "Touching a Nerve: The Self as Brain",
      "author": "Patricia S. Churchland",
      "year": 2013,
      "group": "2. Philosophy of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/churchland-2013-touching-a-nerve",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects a soul existing apart from the brain, and explains near-death experiences by brain states under low oxygen.",
          "cite": "Touching a Nerve (2013), ch. 3 'My Heavens', pp. 70-71; ch. 2 'Soul Searching' not confirmed",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Holds that the self is the brain; does not name filter theory.",
          "cite": "Touching a Nerve (2013), ch. 1 and ch. 2, per reviews and contents",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "hoffman-2019-the-case-against-reality",
      "title": "The Case Against Reality: Why Evolution Hid the Truth from Our Eyes",
      "author": "Donald D. Hoffman",
      "year": 2019,
      "group": "2. Philosophy of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/hoffman-2019-the-case-against-reality",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Does not argue for survival in the passages located; raises it only in interviews.",
          "cite": "The Case Against Reality (2019), passages located through reviews",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Treats brains as interface icons and consciousness as fundamental; offers no filter model.",
          "cite": "The Case Against Reality (2019), final chapter (not confirmed)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "kastrup-2019-idea-of-the-world",
      "title": "The Idea of the World: A Multi-Disciplinary Argument for the Mental Nature of Reality",
      "author": "Bernardo Kastrup",
      "year": 2019,
      "group": "2. Philosophy of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://philpapers.org/rec/KASTIO-6",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/kastrup-2019-idea-of-the-world",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Treats brain activity as the outward image of a dissociated segment of universal mind, recasting filter language within idealism.",
          "cite": "The Idea of the World (2019), Part IV 'Neuroscientific evidence', ch. 11 'Self-transcendence correlates with brain function impairment', p. 178 (title and page from contents listings; passage not read)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "webb-2023-nested-hermeneutics",
      "title": "Nested hermeneutics: Mind at Large as a curated trope of psychedelic experience",
      "author": "Adrian Webb",
      "year": 2023,
      "group": "2. Philosophy of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1080/03080188.2023.2249208",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/webb-2023-nested-hermeneutics",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Argues that Huxley manipulated his quotations of Broad and Bergson to give Mind at Large philosophical standing.",
          "cite": "Nested hermeneutics (2023), Interdisciplinary Science Reviews 48(5): 768-787, abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "jaynes-1976-origin-of-consciousness",
      "title": "The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind",
      "author": "Julian Jaynes",
      "year": 1976,
      "group": "3. Cognitive archaeology and the history of mind",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/jaynes-1976-origin-of-consciousness",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Treats introspective consciousness as learned through language and run by the brain, a production account that leaves nothing beyond the body.",
          "cite": "The Origin of Consciousness (1976), Book I 'The Mind of Man' (inference)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Treats consciousness as learned through language and metaphor.",
          "cite": "The Origin of Consciousness (1976), Book I",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Describes a change from a bicameral mentality to introspective consciousness about 3,000 years ago; speaks to part (a), the split, only.",
          "cite": "The Origin of Consciousness (1976), Book I 'The Mind of Man' and Book II 'The Witness of History'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Reads oracles, possession and hearing voices as vestiges of the bicameral mind.",
              "cite": "The Origin of Consciousness (1976), Book III",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "ong-1982-orality-and-literacy",
      "title": "Orality and Literacy",
      "author": "Walter J. Ong",
      "year": 1982,
      "group": "3. Cognitive archaeology and the history of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/ong-1982-orality-and-literacy",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Studies the shift from orality to literacy, with no claim about a direction of the universe.",
          "cite": "Orality and Literacy (1982), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Argues that writing restructures consciousness; speaks to part (a), the split, only.",
          "cite": "Orality and Literacy (1982), ch. 4",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Describes residual orality persisting inside literate cultures.",
              "cite": "Orality and Literacy (1982), ch. 5",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "summary"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "donald-1991-origins-of-the-modern-mind",
      "title": "Origins of the Modern Mind",
      "author": "Merlin Donald",
      "year": 1991,
      "group": "3. Cognitive archaeology and the history of mind",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/donald-1991-origins-of-the-modern-mind",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Traces stages of memory and culture in human evolution, with no claim about a direction of the universe.",
          "cite": "Origins of the Modern Mind (1991), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Describes the transitions as changes in representation and memory, framed as cognitive and cultural.",
          "cite": "Origins of the Modern Mind (1991), ch. 9 'Consciousness and Indeterminacy'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that each earlier mode of representation is retained in the modern mind.",
              "cite": "Origins of the Modern Mind (1991), ch. 9; Précis, Behavioral and Brain Sciences 16 (1993)",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "mithen-1996-prehistory-of-the-mind",
      "title": "The Prehistory of the Mind",
      "author": "Steven Mithen",
      "year": 1996,
      "group": "3. Cognitive archaeology and the history of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/mithen-1996-prehistory-of-the-mind",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B2",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Uses child development as an analogy for the evolution of mind and warns against strict recapitulation.",
              "cite": "The Prehistory of the Mind (1996), ch. 4 'A new proposal for the mind's evolution', p. 63, as quoted by Evison; ch. 4 begins at p. 61 in a bookseller's contents listing",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Dates cognitive fluidity to 60,000 to 30,000 years ago, earlier than any of the network's dates for Material.",
          "cite": "The Prehistory of the Mind (1996), ch. 9 'The big bang of human culture: the origins of art and religion' (p. 151); pages from a bookseller's contents listing",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "tomasello-1999-cultural-origins",
      "title": "The Cultural Origins of Human Cognition",
      "author": "Michael Tomasello",
      "year": 1999,
      "group": "3. Cognitive archaeology and the history of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/tomasello-1999-cultural-origins",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Traces how children acquire cultural cognition through joint attention, and makes no claim about each person taking part in a cosmic evolution.",
          "cite": "The Cultural Origins of Human Cognition (1999), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "lewis-williams-2002-mind-in-the-cave",
      "title": "The Mind in the Cave",
      "author": "David Lewis-Williams",
      "year": 2002,
      "group": "3. Cognitive archaeology and the history of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/lewis-williams-2002-mind-in-the-cave",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Grounds consciousness and its altered states in the human nervous system, a production account that leaves nothing beyond the body.",
          "cite": "The Mind in the Cave (2002), ch. 4 'The Matter of the Mind' (p. 101) (inference)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Grounds altered-state imagery in the human nervous system, a production model of experience.",
          "cite": "The Mind in the Cave (2002), ch. 4 'The Matter of the Mind' (p. 101) (inference)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Dates the change in mind to the Upper Palaeolithic, earlier than any of the network's dates for Material.",
          "cite": "The Mind in the Cave (2002), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that the same neurological spectrum is present in all modern humans.",
              "cite": "The Mind in the Cave (2002), ch. 4 'The Matter of the Mind' (p. 101)",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "bellah-2011-religion-in-human-evolution",
      "title": "Religion in Human Evolution",
      "author": "Robert N. Bellah",
      "year": 2011,
      "group": "3. Cognitive archaeology and the history of mind",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/bellah-2011-religion-in-human-evolution",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Treats the stages as cultural capacities, with theoretic culture arising in the Axial Age.",
          "cite": "Religion in Human Evolution (2011), Preface (p. ix), ch. 2 'Religion and Evolution' (p. 44), and chs 6 to 9, 'The Axial Age I: Introduction and Ancient Israel' (p. 265) to 'The Axial Age IV: Ancient India'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Holds that earlier capacities such as ritual and narrative persist, while conceding that much of the past itself is lost.",
              "cite": "Religion in Human Evolution (2011), the recurring claim that nothing is ever lost; the concession that much of the past is lost as quoted by Xiao, location not confirmed",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "jung-1959-archetypes-and-the-collective-unconscious",
      "title": "The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious",
      "author": "C. G. Jung",
      "year": 1959,
      "group": "4. Developmental maps",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/jung-1959-archetypes-and-the-collective-unconscious",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Describes individuation as a lifelong process of becoming whole, without measured stages.",
          "cite": "The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious (CW 9i), Part VI: 'Conscious, Unconscious, and Individuation' (p. 275), 'A Study in the Process of Individuation' (p. 290) and 'Concerning Mandala Symbolism' (p. 355)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Holds that an inherited archetypal layer of the psyche stays active in every person, a claim about a universal layer more than about historical structures.",
              "cite": "The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious (CW 9i), Part I: 'Archetypes of the Collective Unconscious' (1934, p. 3) and 'The Concept of the Collective Unconscious' (1936, pp. 42-53)",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "text"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "loevinger-1976-ego-development",
      "title": "Ego Development",
      "author": "Jane Loevinger",
      "year": 1976,
      "group": "4. Developmental maps",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/loevinger-1976-ego-development",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Describes a sequence of ego stages in individuals, and makes no claim about each person taking part in a cosmic evolution.",
          "cite": "Ego Development (1976), chs 1 and 2 (not confirmed against the contents)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "kegan-1982-the-evolving-self",
      "title": "The Evolving Self",
      "author": "Robert Kegan",
      "year": 1982,
      "group": "4. Developmental maps",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/kegan-1982-the-evolving-self",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Describes stages of meaning-making across a life, and makes no claim about each person taking part in a cosmic evolution.",
          "cite": "The Evolving Self (1982), chs 2 to 4 (not confirmed against the contents)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that each new order takes the previous one as object, so earlier orders remain within it.",
              "cite": "The Evolving Self (1982), Part One 'Evolutionary Truces', ch. 3 'The Constitutions of the Self'; titles from a contents listing",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "beck-cowan-spiral-dynamics",
      "title": "Spiral Dynamics",
      "author": "Don Edward Beck and Christopher C. Cowan",
      "year": 1996,
      "group": "4. Developmental maps",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/beck-cowan-spiral-dynamics",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Describes stages of human value systems, with no claim that the universe itself strives.",
          "cite": "Spiral Dynamics (1996), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Presents value systems that people move through, and makes no claim about each person taking part in a cosmic evolution.",
          "cite": "Spiral Dynamics (1996), Section 1 'Overview of Spiral Dynamics', chs 1 to 3",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B2",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Applies the same colour-coded levels to persons, organisations and societies.",
              "cite": "Spiral Dynamics (1996), Parts I and II",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Describes the momentous leap to second-tier thinking that Graves forecast in 1974 as now under way.",
          "cite": "Spiral Dynamics (1996), Section 1, ch. 1 'Different Times Produce Different Minds'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Treats the spiral as an open-ended movement toward greater complexity.",
              "cite": "Spiral Dynamics (1996), Section 1 'Overview of Spiral Dynamics', chs 1 to 3",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "text"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that earlier value systems stay available in every person.",
              "cite": "Spiral Dynamics (1996), Section 1 'Overview of Spiral Dynamics', ch. 2 'The Nature of vMEME Systems' (p. 34) and ch. 3 'The Mind of the Spiral' (p. 48)",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "summary"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C4",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that first-tier value systems resist second-tier thinking.",
              "cite": "Spiral Dynamics (1996), Section 2 'The Dynamics of the Spiral's vMEMEs', ch. 4 'Change and the Spiral' (p. 71) (inference)",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "summary"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "wilber-2000-integral-psychology",
      "title": "Integral Psychology: Consciousness, Spirit, Psychology, Therapy",
      "author": "Ken Wilber",
      "year": 2000,
      "group": "4. Developmental maps",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/wilber-2000-integral-psychology",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds consciousness to be ultimately nondual Spirit, which bears on the step, with no argument that an individual mind persists beyond the body.",
          "cite": "Integral Psychology (2000), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Holds consciousness to be ultimately nondual Spirit.",
          "cite": "Integral Psychology (2000), Part Three, ch. 8 'The Archeology of Spirit' and ch. 15 'The Integral Embrace'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Treats evolution as Spirit in action moving toward greater depth.",
          "cite": "Integral Psychology (2000), Part Three, ch. 8 'The Archeology of Spirit'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Correlates over a hundred developmental models in charts of stages.",
          "cite": "Integral Psychology (2000), charts",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B2",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds individual and cultural development broadly parallel, with stated limits.",
              "cite": "Integral Psychology (2000), Part Three, ch. 12 'Sociocultural Evolution' (inference)",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "summary"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Describes an integral stage emerging in a small share of adults.",
          "cite": "Integral Psychology (2000), Part Three, ch. 12 'Sociocultural Evolution' and ch. 13 'From Modernity to Postmodernity'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Treats evolution as Spirit in action moving toward greater depth.",
              "cite": "Integral Psychology (2000), Part Three, ch. 8 'The Archeology of Spirit'",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "summary"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Uses Gebser's archaic, magic, mythic, mental and integral structures as stages of consciousness; speaks to part (a), the split, only.",
          "cite": "Integral Psychology (2000), Part Three, ch. 12 'Sociocultural Evolution' (inference)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that each stage transcends and includes its predecessors.",
              "cite": "Integral Psychology (2000), Part One",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "fantappie-1942-unitary-theory-of-the-physical-and-biological-world",
      "title": "Principi di una teoria unitaria del mondo fisico e biologico",
      "author": "Luigi Fantappiè",
      "year": 1942,
      "group": "5. Complexity and cosmic evolution",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/fantappie-1942-unitary-theory-of-the-physical-and-biological-world",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Proposes syntropy, a converging, future-caused tendency toward order and differentiation in living systems, symmetrical to entropy, without a stated claim that complexity has risen historically.",
          "cite": "Principi di una teoria unitaria del mondo fisico e biologico (Rome, 1944); section not confirmed",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Proposes syntropy, a converging, future-caused tendency toward order and differentiation in living systems, symmetrical to entropy, without a stated claim that complexity has risen historically.",
              "cite": "Principi di una teoria unitaria del mondo fisico e biologico (Rome, 1944); section not confirmed",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "vernadsky-1945-biosphere-and-noosphere",
      "title": "The Biosphere and the Noösphere",
      "author": "W. I. Vernadsky",
      "year": 1945,
      "group": "5. Complexity and cosmic evolution",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/vernadsky-1945-biosphere-and-noosphere",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that the biosphere is passing into a noosphere, a geological stage driven by scientific thought; names no growth curve or individual drawing on it.",
          "cite": "The Biosphere and the Noösphere, American Scientist 33(1) (January 1945): 1-12, p. 10, as cited in Oldfield and Shaw (2006)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "teilhard-1955-the-phenomenon-of-man",
      "title": "The Phenomenon of Man",
      "author": "Pierre Teilhard de Chardin",
      "year": 1955,
      "group": "5. Complexity and cosmic evolution",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/teilhard-1955-the-phenomenon-of-man",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that the universe conserves persons through their convergence on Omega.",
          "cite": "The Phenomenon of Man (1955; Eng. 1959), Book Four 'Survival', ch. II 'Beyond the Collective: the Hyper-Personal'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that a rudimentary within rises with brain complexity; proposes no filter.",
          "cite": "The Phenomenon of Man (1955; Eng. 1959), Book One 'Before Life Came', ch. II 'The Within of Things'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "States a law of complexity-consciousness leading toward an Omega Point.",
          "cite": "The Phenomenon of Man (1955), Books Three and Four",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Describes humanity converging toward a higher unity of thought.",
          "cite": "The Phenomenon of Man (1955), Book Four",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "States a law of complexity-consciousness leading toward an Omega Point.",
              "cite": "The Phenomenon of Man (1955), Books Three and Four",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Names the thinking layer that envelops the Earth the noosphere.",
          "cite": "The Phenomenon of Man (1955), Book Three",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "berry-1988-dream-of-the-earth",
      "title": "The Dream of the Earth",
      "author": "Thomas Berry",
      "year": 1988,
      "group": "5. Complexity and cosmic evolution",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://cmc.marmot.org/Record/.b11467721",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/berry-1988-dream-of-the-earth",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Argues that education should enable each student to understand the universe story and their own role in creating its next phase.",
          "cite": "The Dream of the Earth (1988), ch. 8 'The American College in the Ecological Age', p. 98, and ch. 10 'The New Story', pp. 123-137, esp. p. 136 (as quoted by the Thomas Berry Foundation)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "maynard-smith-szathmary-1995-major-transitions",
      "title": "The Major Transitions in Evolution",
      "author": "John Maynard Smith, Eörs Szathmáry",
      "year": 1995,
      "group": "5. Complexity and cosmic evolution",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/maynard-smith-szathmary-1995-major-transitions",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Defines transitions as changes in how information is stored and passed on, with no necessary direction.",
          "cite": "The Major Transitions in Evolution (1995), ch. 1",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Defines transitions as changes in how information is stored and passed on, with no necessary direction.",
              "cite": "The Major Transitions in Evolution (1995), ch. 1",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "prigogine-1996-the-end-of-certainty",
      "title": "The End of Certainty: Time, Chaos, and the New Laws of Nature",
      "author": "Ilya Prigogine",
      "year": 1996,
      "group": "5. Complexity and cosmic evolution",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/prigogine-1996-the-end-of-certainty",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Models order arising from irreversible processes far from equilibrium, with no claim that the universe strives and none about consciousness.",
          "cite": "The End of Certainty (1997 English edition), chs 1 to 3",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Argues that irreversible processes far from equilibrium create order and give nature an arrow of time, with no claim about consciousness.",
              "cite": "The End of Certainty (1997 English edition), chs 1 to 3",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "summary"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "sahtouris-earthdance",
      "title": "EarthDance: Living Systems in Evolution",
      "author": "Elisabet Sahtouris",
      "year": 2000,
      "group": "5. Complexity and cosmic evolution",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": "https://www.amazon.com/dp/0595130674",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/sahtouris-earthdance",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that Indigenous peoples have always known the universe is participatory, which Western scientists only now acknowledge.",
          "cite": "EarthDance (2000), A Note from the Author; ch. 15 'Less Than Perfect, More Than Machine'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Describes a self-imposed separation from nature through a mechanical worldview over the past few millennia; speaks to part (a) only.",
          "cite": "EarthDance (2000), A Note from the Author",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that humanity can mature like other species from competition to cooperation, and names no Noosphere and no S-curve.",
          "cite": "EarthDance (2000), A Note from the Author; ch. 17, 'A Matter of Maturation' (opening read)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Argues that cooperation between the ways of indigenous and industrial peoples is needed to build a sustainable world.",
          "cite": "EarthDance (2000), A Note from the Author; ch. 19 'The Indigenous Way' (opening read)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "chaisson-2001-cosmic-evolution",
      "title": "Cosmic Evolution",
      "author": "Eric J. Chaisson",
      "year": 2001,
      "group": "5. Complexity and cosmic evolution",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/chaisson-2001-cosmic-evolution",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Measures energy rate density rising across cosmic, biological and cultural systems, with no claim that the universe strives.",
          "cite": "Cosmic Evolution (2001), 'Discussion: Evolution, Broadly Considered' (pp. 148-208) (inference from the JSTOR contents and a reviewer's quotation of p. 180); chs 2 and 3 are 'Radiation' and 'Life'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Measures energy rate density rising from galaxies and stars to plants, animals and societies.",
              "cite": "Cosmic Evolution (2001), 'Discussion: Evolution, Broadly Considered' (pp. 148-208) (inference from the JSTOR contents and a reviewer's quotation of p. 180); chs 2 and 3 are 'Radiation' and 'Life'",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "laszlo-2004-science-and-the-akashic-field",
      "title": "Science and the Akashic Field: An Integral Theory of Everything",
      "author": "Ervin Laszlo",
      "year": 2004,
      "group": "5. Complexity and cosmic evolution",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/laszlo-2004-science-and-the-akashic-field",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds the quantum-vacuum A-field to be the common ground of matter and psyche, with consciousness one aspect of that ground.",
          "cite": "Science and the Akashic Field (2004), Parts One and Two (not checked)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that a quantum-vacuum information field conserves all experience, which minds access by resonance; does not cast the brain explicitly as a filter.",
          "cite": "Science and the Akashic Field (2004), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Argues that evolution in nature and in mind moves toward greater coherence and integration.",
          "cite": "Science and the Akashic Field (2004), Part Two (not checked)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Argues that evolution in nature and in mind moves toward greater coherence and integration.",
              "cite": "Science and the Akashic Field (2004), Part Two (not checked)",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "christian-2011-big-history-project",
      "title": "Big History Project",
      "author": "David Christian",
      "year": 2011,
      "group": "5. Complexity and cosmic evolution",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/christian-2011-big-history-project",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Teaches the universe's history as one story in middle and high schools; shows such a story has been widely taught.",
          "cite": "Big History Project course (launched 2011), as described by Education Week (8 September 2014)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "swimme-tucker-2011-journey-of-the-universe",
      "title": "Journey of the Universe",
      "author": "Brian Thomas Swimme; Mary Evelyn Tucker",
      "year": 2011,
      "group": "5. Complexity and cosmic evolution",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://yalebooks.yale.edu/book/9780300209433/journey-of-the-universe/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/swimme-tucker-2011-journey-of-the-universe",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Presents humans as emerging within, and acting in, the universe's story.",
          "cite": "Journey of the Universe (2011), whole book, per publisher summary",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "montessori-1948-to-educate-the-human-potential",
      "title": "To Educate the Human Potential",
      "author": "Maria Montessori",
      "year": 1948,
      "group": "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/montessori-1948-to-educate-the-human-potential",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that children should be taught their part in a cosmic plan; shows the idea has been taught.",
          "cite": "To Educate the Human Potential (1948; 2nd impr. 1955), Introduction, p. 2, and ch. 1 'The Six-year-old Confronted with the Cosmic Plan', pp. 4-10; the p. 10 reference not confirmed",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "gebser-ever-present-origin",
      "title": "The Ever-Present Origin",
      "author": "Jean Gebser",
      "year": 1949,
      "group": "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/gebser-ever-present-origin",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Describes structures of consciousness and an ever-present spiritual origin, and does not address a person's consciousness beyond the body.",
          "cite": "The Ever-Present Origin, chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Treats origin as an ever-present spiritual ground beyond all structures.",
          "cite": "The Ever-Present Origin, Part One",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Calls the changes mutations and declines to read them as progress.",
          "cite": "The Ever-Present Origin, Part One, p. 41 (Ohio University Press, 1985), as quoted by Maxwell",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Sees an integral, aperspectival structure emerging in the twentieth century.",
          "cite": "The Ever-Present Origin, Part Two",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Calls the changes mutations and declines to read them as progress.",
              "cite": "The Ever-Present Origin, Part One, p. 41 (Ohio University Press, 1985), as quoted by Maxwell",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Describes mutations in how awareness is organised in space and time, from archaic to integral; speaks to part (a), the split, only.",
          "cite": "The Ever-Present Origin, Part One",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that earlier structures remain active in every person.",
              "cite": "The Ever-Present Origin, Part One",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C4",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Describes the mental-rational structure in its deficient phase.",
              "cite": "The Ever-Present Origin, Part One",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "jaspers-1949-origin-and-goal-of-history",
      "title": "The Origin and Goal of History",
      "author": "Karl Jaspers",
      "year": 1949,
      "group": "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/jaspers-1949-origin-and-goal-of-history",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Sees a common axis of history while rejecting a single law of development.",
          "cite": "The Origin and Goal of History (1949), Part One 'World History' and Part Three 'The Meaning of History'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Denies that modern European science and technology form a second axis, while allowing a remote second Axial Period may still come.",
          "cite": "The Origin and Goal of History (1949), Part One, ch. 2 'Schema of World History' (p. 25 of the 1953 translation, per Wirtz) and Part Two 'Present and Future', ch. 9 'The Intrinsically New: Science and Technology'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Sees a common axis of history while rejecting a single law of development.",
              "cite": "The Origin and Goal of History (1949), Part One 'World History' and Part Three 'The Meaning of History'",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Proposes an Axial Age when people became conscious of being as a whole and of themselves; speaks to part (a), the split, only.",
          "cite": "The Origin and Goal of History (1949), Part One, ch. 1 'The Axial Period'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "barfield-1957-saving-the-appearances",
      "title": "Saving the Appearances",
      "author": "Owen Barfield",
      "year": 1957,
      "group": "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/barfield-1957-saving-the-appearances",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Traces how participation in the phenomenal world has changed through history, and does not address consciousness apart from the body.",
          "cite": "Saving the Appearances (1957), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Holds that the phenomenal world arises together with consciousness.",
          "cite": "Saving the Appearances (1957), chs 1 to 4, 'The Rainbow' to 'Participation'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Calls for a final participation that is conscious.",
          "cite": "Saving the Appearances (1957), ch. 20 'Final Participation', with chs 21 to 25",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Argues original participation gave way to the onlooker consciousness of modern science; speaks to part (a), the split, only.",
          "cite": "Saving the Appearances (1957), chs 6 to 14, 'Original Participation' to 'Before and After the Scientific Revolution'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C4",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that treating appearances as literal objects keeps the onlooker mode in place.",
              "cite": "Saving the Appearances (1957), ch. 9 'An Evolution of Idols' and ch. 19 'Symptoms of Iconoclasm'",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "trible-1978-god-and-the-rhetoric-of-sexuality",
      "title": "God and the Rhetoric of Sexuality",
      "author": "Phyllis Trible",
      "year": 1978,
      "group": "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.fortresspress.com/store/product/9780800604646/God-and-the-Rhetoric-of-Sexuality",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/trible-1978-god-and-the-rhetoric-of-sexuality",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Speaks to part (a) only: reads the Eden story as a love story gone awry, a rupture between woman and man.",
          "cite": "God and the Rhetoric of Sexuality (1978), ch. 4 'A Love Story Gone Awry', pp. 73-143",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "eisler-1987-chalice-and-the-blade",
      "title": "The Chalice and the Blade: Our History, Our Future",
      "author": "Riane Eisler",
      "year": 1987,
      "group": "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/eisler-1987-chalice-and-the-blade",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Argues that dominator societies displaced earlier partnership societies and reads the Eden story as a trace of the shift; speaks to part (a) only.",
          "cite": "The Chalice and the Blade (1987), chapters not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "deloria-1995-red-earth-white-lies",
      "title": "Red Earth, White Lies: Native Americans and the Myth of Scientific Fact",
      "author": "Vine Deloria Jr.",
      "year": 1995,
      "group": "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://library.sarsf.org/bib/9066",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/deloria-1995-red-earth-white-lies",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds, on part (b), that tribal oral traditions preserve accurate knowledge of the deep past, against scientific orthodoxy; silent on parts (a) and (c).",
          "cite": "Red Earth, White Lies (1995), whole argument as summarised in the catalogue record and three reviews; chapters not read",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "quinn-1996-story-of-b",
      "title": "The Story of B",
      "author": "Daniel Quinn",
      "year": 1996,
      "group": "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/quinn-1996-story-of-b",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Argues, on part (a), that one culture broke from humanity's older ways through agriculture, and reads the Fall story as that change of mind.",
          "cite": "The Story of B (1996), 'Educating Jared', pp. 45-103, and B's lectures, as summarised by Do the Math (UC San Diego); page of the Fall passage not confirmed",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "odora-hoppers-2002-indigenous-knowledge-integration-knowledge-systems",
      "title": "Indigenous Knowledge and the Integration of Knowledge Systems: Towards a Philosophy of Articulation",
      "author": "Catherine A. Odora Hoppers (ed.)",
      "year": 2002,
      "group": "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://search.worldcat.org/title/indigenous-knowledge-and-the-integration-of-knowledge-systems-towards-a-philosophy-of-articulation/oclc/51002858",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/odora-hoppers-2002-indigenous-knowledge-integration-knowledge-systems",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Treats, on part (b), African indigenous knowledge systems as able to help heal colonial harms and transform institutions; silent on parts (a) and (c).",
          "cite": "Indigenous Knowledge and the Integration of Knowledge Systems (2002), editor's chapter 'Indigenous Knowledge and the Integration of Knowledge Systems: Towards a Conceptual and Methodological Framework' (pp. 2-22, per Horsthemke), with the whole volume as described in the AfricaBib abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Argues for integrating indigenous knowledge systems with the sciences, through a philosophy of articulation that transforms research, higher education and policy.",
          "cite": "Indigenous Knowledge and the Integration of Knowledge Systems (2002), 'The Place of Indigenous Knowledge Systems in the Post-Postmodern' (p. 257), with the editor's chapter 'Indigenous Knowledge and the Integration of Knowledge Systems: Towards a Conceptual and Methodological Framework' (pp. 2-22, per Horsthemke)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "taylor-2005-the-fall",
      "title": "The Fall: The Insanity of the Ego in Human History and the Dawning of a New Era",
      "author": "Steve Taylor",
      "year": 2005,
      "group": "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.stevenmtaylor.com/books/the-fall/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/taylor-2005-the-fall",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Argues that an Ego Explosion some 6,000 years ago ended an earlier way of life free of war and patriarchy; speaks to part (a) only.",
          "cite": "The Fall (2005), Part One, chs. 2-5 (titles only checked)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "mcgilchrist-2009-master-and-his-emissary",
      "title": "The Master and His Emissary",
      "author": "Iain McGilchrist",
      "year": 2009,
      "group": "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/mcgilchrist-2009-master-and-his-emissary",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Ties shifts in Western culture to the balance between the brain's hemispheres; speaks to part (a), the split, only.",
          "cite": "The Master and His Emissary (2009), Part Two 'How the Brain Has Shaped Our World'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that both hemispheric modes are present in every person.",
              "cite": "The Master and His Emissary (2009), Part One",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C4",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Argues that the left hemisphere's mode now dominates Western culture.",
              "cite": "The Master and His Emissary (2009), Part Two, final chapters",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "meyers-2013-rediscovering-eve",
      "title": "Rediscovering Eve: Ancient Israelite Women in Context",
      "author": "Carol Meyers",
      "year": 2013,
      "group": "6. Cultural and historical theorists",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://global.oup.com/academic/product/rediscovering-eve-9780199734627",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/meyers-2013-rediscovering-eve",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects, on part (a), reading Genesis 2-3 as a Fall; reads it as explaining the toil and childbearing of Iron Age farm life.",
          "cite": "Rediscovering Eve (2013), ch. 4 'Eve in Eden: Genesis 2-3' and ch. 5 'Eve out of Eden: Genesis 3:16', titles from the catalogue contents and Weiss (2013); not read",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "mcintosh-2007-integral-consciousness",
      "title": "Integral Consciousness and the Future of Evolution",
      "author": "Steve McIntosh",
      "year": 2007,
      "group": "7. Metacrisis and the mycelial turn",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/mcintosh-2007-integral-consciousness",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Holds that evolution has a direction toward greater value.",
          "cite": "Integral Consciousness and the Future of Evolution (2007), Part II 'A Deeper Discussion', ch. 10 'The Directions of Evolution' (not confirmed)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Holds that individuals, like cultures, move through a sequence of worldview stages.",
          "cite": "Integral Consciousness and the Future of Evolution (2007), Part I, ch. 3 'Stages of Consciousness and Culture' (p. 29); the part title 'The Main Narrative' not confirmed",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B2",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Treats worldviews as stages of cultural evolution, drawing on Graves and Wilber.",
              "cite": "Integral Consciousness and the Future of Evolution (2007), Part I, ch. 3 'Stages of Consciousness and Culture' (p. 29)",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "abstract"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Describes an integral worldview emerging after the postmodern one.",
          "cite": "Integral Consciousness and the Future of Evolution (2007), Part I, ch. 4 'The Integral Stage of Consciousness' (chapter title not confirmed)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that evolution has a direction toward greater value.",
              "cite": "Integral Consciousness and the Future of Evolution (2007), Part II 'A Deeper Discussion', ch. 10 'The Directions of Evolution' (not confirmed)",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that each worldview's healthy values are carried forward.",
              "cite": "Integral Consciousness and the Future of Evolution (2007), Part I, ch. 3, with the ch. 4 section 'Practicing the Integral Lifestyle: Value Metabolism' (section title not confirmed)",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "abstract"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C4",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that modern and postmodern worldviews resist integration.",
              "cite": "Integral Consciousness and the Future of Evolution (2007), Part I, chs 3 and 4 (inference)",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "summary"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "briggs-2021-emerging-world",
      "title": "Emerging World: The Evolution of Consciousness and the Future of Humanity",
      "author": "Roger P. Briggs",
      "year": 2021,
      "group": "7. Metacrisis and the mycelial turn",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": "https://rogerpbriggs.org/books",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/briggs-2021-emerging-world",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Poses the after-death question and reports traditions that hold awareness survives the body, leaving it conditional; science, he says, cannot verify them.",
          "cite": "Emerging World (2021), ch. 2, pp. 80-81",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Holds that intuition brings non-local knowledge past senses and memory, and that the heart registers future events, citing Bem's meta-analysis.",
          "cite": "Emerging World (2021), ch. 6, pp. 197, 220",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds it possible that the brain also acts as a receiver tuned to informational fields, beside the mainstream view that it produces consciousness.",
          "cite": "Emerging World (2021), ch. 6, pp. 198-200, 221",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that evolution is a pervasive tendency of the universe generating new forms, and offers the inevitability of self-aware beings as speculation.",
          "cite": "Emerging World (2021), ch. 5, pp. 159, 183-184",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Calls on all who are capable to support the shift to Planetary consciousness, and holds that school history covers only the last 5,000 years.",
          "cite": "Emerging World (2021), ch. 5, pp. 168, 179-180",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Sets wholeness as a mark of the emerging Planetary stage, and holds that its emergence is not guaranteed.",
          "cite": "Emerging World (2021), ch. 5, pp. 170, 180",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that evolution is one pervasive tendency of the universe, ceaselessly generating new forms, culture and consciousness among them.",
              "cite": "Emerging World (2021), ch. 5, p. 159",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "text"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Dates a Material stage of separation from nature to the first civilisations; speaks to part (a), with no curve and no Eden reading.",
          "cite": "Emerging World (2021), ch. 5, pp. 161-166",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Expects a critical mass of people to carry society into Planetary consciousness, and names no Noosphere and no S-curve.",
          "cite": "Emerging World (2021), ch. 5, pp. 160, 182",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "simard-2021-finding-the-mother-tree",
      "title": "Finding the Mother Tree",
      "author": "Suzanne Simard",
      "year": 2021,
      "group": "7. Metacrisis and the mycelial turn",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/simard-2021-finding-the-mother-tree",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Offers the forest network as a model for human cooperation, and makes no claim about drawing on a Noosphere.",
          "cite": "Finding the Mother Tree (2021), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "schmachtenberger-2022-third-attractor",
      "title": "In Search of the Third Attractor (parts 1 and 2)",
      "author": "Daniel Schmachtenberger",
      "year": 2022,
      "group": "7. Metacrisis and the mycelial turn",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/schmachtenberger-2022-third-attractor",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Presents a third attractor as a path humanity must choose, with no trend toward wholeness built into the universe.",
          "cite": "In Search of the Third Attractor (2022), parts 1 and 2, chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Calls for collective sensemaking and choice at the scale of present risks, with no Noosphere and no S-curve.",
          "cite": "In Search of the Third Attractor (2022), Part 1, segment 'Sensemaking', with Part 2, segment 'Education'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C4",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds that rivalry dynamics and current incentives block that path.",
              "cite": "In Search of the Third Attractor, Part 2, segments 'Hyper Agents' (00:15:06) and 'Great Game of Power' (00:26:55), with Part 1, segment 'Catastrophic Risk' (00:25:08)",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "summary"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "aurobindo-1939-the-life-divine",
      "title": "The Life Divine",
      "author": "Sri Aurobindo",
      "year": 1939,
      "group": "8. Traditions and testimony",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/aurobindo-1939-the-life-divine",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Argues that the soul survives death and returns through rebirth as part of its evolution.",
          "cite": "The Life Divine, Book Two, ch. XX 'The Philosophy of Rebirth' and ch. XXII 'Rebirth and Other Worlds; Karma, the Soul and Immortality' (pp. 771 and 823 in the Complete Works edition)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds consciousness to be the fundamental reality involved in matter, with no model of the brain as a filter.",
          "cite": "The Life Divine (1939), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Holds evolution to be the progressive emergence of Spirit in matter.",
          "cite": "The Life Divine (1939-40), Book Two (Vol. II, 1940)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Foresees a supramental consciousness emerging in humanity.",
          "cite": "The Life Divine, Book Two, closing chapters, including ch. XXVI 'The Ascent towards Supermind' and the final chapter 'The Divine Life'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Holds evolution to be the progressive emergence of Spirit in matter.",
              "cite": "The Life Divine (1939-40), Book Two (Vol. II, 1940)",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "abstract"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "lau-1963-tao-te-ching",
      "title": "Tao Te Ching",
      "author": "Laozi; D. C. Lau (translator)",
      "year": 1963,
      "group": "8. Traditions and testimony",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/lau-1963-tao-te-ching",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Renders the Dao's movement as turning back, and names no forward end-point in chapter 40.",
          "cite": "Tao Te Ching (1963), ch. 40 (p. 47 known from one secondary note; not checked against the Penguin text)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "elkins-rueckert-mccarty-1984-ra-material",
      "title": "The Ra Material: The Law of One, Book I",
      "author": "Don Elkins; Carla Rueckert; James Allen McCarty",
      "year": 1984,
      "group": "8. Traditions and testimony",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://assets.llresearch.org/books/the_law_of_one_book_1.pdf",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/elkins-rueckert-mccarty-1984-ra-material",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Teaches that the self continues across incarnations and densities beyond any one body.",
          "cite": "The Ra Contact, Session 21 (10 February 1981), 21.9-21.10",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Teaches that all beings progress through densities toward the eighth, or octave, where creation becomes one with the Creator again.",
          "cite": "The Ra Contact, Session 16 (31 January 1981), 16.21-16.22 and 16.38 (Book I)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "barr-1992-garden-of-eden-hope-of-immortality",
      "title": "The Garden of Eden and the Hope of Immortality",
      "author": "James Barr",
      "year": 1992,
      "group": "8. Traditions and testimony",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://openlibrary.org/works/OL4096422W/The_Garden_of_Eden_and_the_hope_of_immortality",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/barr-1992-garden-of-eden-hope-of-immortality",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects reading Genesis 2 and 3 as a fall and holds humans imperfect from the start; addresses the Eden reading of part (a).",
          "cite": "The Garden of Eden and the Hope of Immortality (1992), p. ix, as quoted in Fretheim (1994)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "fretheim-1994-is-genesis-3-a-fall-story",
      "title": "Is Genesis 3 a Fall Story?",
      "author": "Terence E. Fretheim",
      "year": 1994,
      "group": "8. Traditions and testimony",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://wordandworld.luthersem.edu/wp-content/uploads/pdfs/14-2_Genesis/Is%20Genesis%203%20a%20Fall%20Story.pdf",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/fretheim-1994-is-genesis-3-a-fall-story",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Reads Genesis 3 as estrangement from God through sin and rejects an upward fall to higher self-consciousness; speaks to the Eden reading of part (a).",
          "cite": "Is Genesis 3 a Fall Story? (1994), pp. 144-148",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "wilson-2008-research-is-ceremony",
      "title": "Research Is Ceremony: Indigenous Research Methods",
      "author": "Shawn Wilson",
      "year": 2008,
      "group": "8. Traditions and testimony",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://catdir.loc.gov/catdir/toc/fy1002/2008431436.html",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/wilson-2008-research-is-ceremony",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Speaks to part (b) only: sets out relational Indigenous ways of knowing as a living, shared paradigm.",
          "cite": "Research Is Ceremony (2008), ch. 4 'The Elements of an Indigenous Research Paradigm' and ch. 5 'Relationality'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "ziporyn-2009-zhuangzi-essential-writings",
      "title": "Zhuangzi: The Essential Writings, with Selections from Traditional Commentaries",
      "author": "Zhuangzi; Brook Ziporyn (translator)",
      "year": 2009,
      "group": "8. Traditions and testimony",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://hackettpublishing.com/zhuangzi-the-essential-writings",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/ziporyn-2009-zhuangzi-essential-writings",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Reads the Zhuangzi as ceaseless transformation of perspectives whose source cannot be known; states no direction or end.",
          "cite": "Ziporyn, 'Zhuangzi as Philosopher' (Hackett online essay keyed to the 2009 edition)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "bache-2019-lsd-and-the-mind-of-the-universe",
      "title": "LSD and the Mind of the Universe: Diamonds from Heaven",
      "author": "Christopher M. Bache",
      "year": 2019,
      "group": "8. Traditions and testimony",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/bache-2019-lsd-and-the-mind-of-the-universe",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Holds that reincarnation gives individual consciousness open-ended time to develop.",
          "cite": "LSD and the Mind of the Universe (2019), p. 91, as quoted in a review",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Reports direct experience of a living intelligence underlying the universe, from which individual minds arise.",
          "cite": "LSD and the Mind of the Universe (2019), ch. 6 'Initiation into the Universe' and ch. 10 'Diamond Luminosity' (inference)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Reads the evolution of consciousness as purposeful, moving toward a deeper union of the human with a cosmic intelligence.",
          "cite": "LSD and the Mind of the Universe (2019), ch. 9 'The Birth of the Future Human' and ch. 11 'Final Vision' (inference)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Reports visions of a coming transformation of the human species, which he calls the birth of the Future Human.",
          "cite": "LSD and the Mind of the Universe (2019), chapter on the birth of the Future Human",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "affirms",
              "says": "Reads the evolution of consciousness as purposeful, moving toward a deeper union of the human with a cosmic intelligence.",
              "cite": "LSD and the Mind of the Universe (2019), ch. 9 'The Birth of the Future Human' and ch. 11 'Final Vision' (inference)",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Describes humanity as a single species mind, in which personal healing feeds a collective change.",
          "cite": "LSD and the Mind of the Universe (2019), middle chapters",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "yunkaporta-2019-sand-talk",
      "title": "Sand Talk",
      "author": "Tyson Yunkaporta",
      "year": 2019,
      "group": "8. Traditions and testimony",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/yunkaporta-2019-sand-talk",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects narratives of civilisational progress as patterns that cannot be sustained.",
          "cite": "Sand Talk (2019), opening chapter, 'The Porcupine, the Paleo-mind and the Grand Design'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "dissents",
              "says": "Rejects narratives of civilisational progress as patterns that cannot be sustained.",
              "cite": "Sand Talk (2019), opening chapter, 'The Porcupine, the Paleo-mind and the Grand Design'",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "summary"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Presents knowledge held in relations as long-standing Aboriginal practice, and makes no claim about a Noosphere or a growth curve.",
          "cite": "Sand Talk (2019), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Sets Indigenous pattern thinking against industrial systems, with any joining on Indigenous terms.",
          "cite": "Sand Talk (2019), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "whitty-2025-on-telepathy-tapes",
      "title": "On Telepathy Tapes",
      "author": "Danny Whitty",
      "year": 2025,
      "group": "8. Traditions and testimony",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://dannywithwords.com/2025/01/27/on-telepathy-tapes/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/whitty-2025-on-telepathy-tapes",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Trusts peers who report telepathy while reporting none himself; objects that the podcast harms access to spelling.",
          "cite": "On Telepathy Tapes (27 January 2025), whole post",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "butterfield-1931-whig-interpretation-of-history",
      "title": "The Whig Interpretation of History",
      "author": "Herbert Butterfield",
      "year": 1931,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/butterfield-1931-whig-interpretation-of-history",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects reading history as progress toward the present; speaks to the writing of history only.",
          "cite": "The Whig Interpretation of History (1931), Preface (dated September 1931) and the essay as a whole",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "popper-poverty-of-historicism",
      "title": "The Poverty of Historicism",
      "author": "Karl Popper",
      "year": 1957,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/popper-poverty-of-historicism",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues history has no laws of development that permit prediction.",
          "cite": "The Poverty of Historicism (1957), Part IV",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Holds that claims about the coming stage of history cannot be tested.",
          "cite": "The Poverty of Historicism (1957), Preface and Part IV",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "dissents",
              "says": "Argues history has no laws of development that permit prediction.",
              "cite": "The Poverty of Historicism (1957), Part IV",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "medawar-1961-review-phenomenon-of-man",
      "title": "Review of The Phenomenon of Man",
      "author": "Peter B. Medawar",
      "year": 1961,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/medawar-1961-review-phenomenon-of-man",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Criticises Teilhard's book without discussing survival of bodily death.",
          "cite": "Review of The Phenomenon of Man, Mind 70(277): 99-106 (1961)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Does not discuss whether the brain filters consciousness.",
          "cite": "Review of The Phenomenon of Man, Mind 70(277): 99-106 (1961)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects Teilhard's directed evolution as lacking biological support.",
          "cite": "Review of The Phenomenon of Man, Mind 70(277): 99-106 (1961), p. 103",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects Teilhard's claim that consciousness must culminate in a supreme consciousness at Omega, treating it as metaphysics expounded with mounting confusion.",
          "cite": "Review of The Phenomenon of Man, Mind 70(277): 99-106 (1961), pp. 104-105",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "dissents",
              "says": "Rejects Teilhard's directed evolution as lacking biological support.",
              "cite": "Review of The Phenomenon of Man, Mind 70(277): 99-106 (1961), p. 103",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "text"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Dismisses Teilhard's account of noogenesis and the noosphere as a fatuous argument that needs only exposition to expose it.",
          "cite": "Review of The Phenomenon of Man, Mind 70(277): 99-106 (1961), pp. 102-103",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "block-1981-review-of-jaynes",
      "title": "Review of The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind",
      "author": "Ned Block",
      "year": 1981,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/block-1981-review-of-jaynes",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues Jaynes confuses a change in the concept of consciousness with a change in consciousness, disputing part (a).",
          "cite": "Review of Jaynes, Cognition and Brain Theory 4 (1981)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "street-1984-literacy-in-theory-and-practice",
      "title": "Literacy in Theory and Practice",
      "author": "Brian V. Street",
      "year": 1984,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/street-1984-literacy-in-theory-and-practice",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects the claim that literacy changes how the mind works, disputing a split in mind tied to writing, part (a).",
          "cite": "Literacy in Theory and Practice (1984), Part I, chs 1 and 2",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Treats oral and literate modes as overlapping social practices and rejects the great divide on which talk of residual orality rests.",
              "cite": "Literacy in Theory and Practice (1984)",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "summary"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "habermas-1985-philosophical-discourse-of-modernity",
      "title": "The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity: Twelve Lectures",
      "author": "Jürgen Habermas",
      "year": 1985,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/habermas-1985-philosophical-discourse-of-modernity",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Argues for completing modernity through reason, with no claim that the universe trends toward wholeness.",
          "cite": "The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity (1985), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C4",
              "position": "dissents",
              "says": "Disputes that rational modernity is a deficient mode to be left behind, while granting that subject-centred reason has pathologies.",
              "cite": "The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity (1985), Lecture XI 'An Alternative Way out of the Philosophy of the Subject: Communicative versus Subject-Centered Reason' (p. 294) and Lecture XII 'The Normative Content of Modernity' (p. 336), MIT Press and Polity pagination",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "abstract"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "gould-1989-wonderful-life",
      "title": "Wonderful Life: The Burgess Shale and the Nature of History",
      "author": "Stephen Jay Gould",
      "year": 1989,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/gould-1989-wonderful-life",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that life's history is contingent, so a replay would likely differ; rejects a built-in direction toward humans.",
          "cite": "Wonderful Life (1989), pp. 48-51 (as quoted in secondary sources)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "dennett-1991-consciousness-explained",
      "title": "Consciousness Explained",
      "author": "Daniel C. Dennett",
      "year": 1991,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": true,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/dennett-1991-consciousness-explained",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Ties experience to parallel processes in the brain and treats the self as a construct of language and culture.",
          "cite": "Consciousness Explained (1991), ch. 5 'Multiple Drafts Versus the Cartesian Theater' and ch. 13 'The Reality of Selves'; chapter titles from a contents listing",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Explains experience through multiple drafts produced by parallel processes in the brain, a production model.",
          "cite": "Consciousness Explained (1991), ch. 5 'Multiple Drafts Versus the Cartesian Theater'; ch. 9 'The Architecture of the Human Mind' (inference); chapter titles from a contents listing",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Treats the conscious mind as a virtual machine installed by culture, with no dated transition.",
          "cite": "Consciousness Explained (1991), ch. 7 'The Evolution of Consciousness', section 'The Memes of Consciousness: The Virtual Machine to Be Installed'; from a contents listing",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "segal-1991-joseph-campbells-mythology",
      "title": "Joseph Campbell's Mythology: A Review Essay",
      "author": "Robert A. Segal",
      "year": 1991,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/segal-1991-joseph-campbells-mythology",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects Campbell's claim of one pattern shared by all hero myths, as disregarding differences and believers.",
          "cite": "Southern Humanities Review 25(3) (1991): 267-275",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "siegler-1996-emerging-minds",
      "title": "Emerging Minds: The Process of Change in Children's Thinking",
      "author": "Robert S. Siegler",
      "year": 1996,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/siegler-1996-emerging-minds",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Models change in children's thinking as overlapping waves of strategies, and makes no claim about each person taking part in a cosmic evolution.",
          "cite": "Emerging Minds (1996), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Accepts that older and newer strategies coexist for long periods, and holds that older ones decline and some are abandoned.",
              "cite": "Emerging Minds (1996), ch. 4, overlapping waves model (Fig. 4.4)",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "text"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "gould-1996-full-house",
      "title": "Full House",
      "author": "Stephen Jay Gould",
      "year": 1996,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/gould-1996-full-house",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues apparent progress is spread away from a wall of minimal complexity, with bacteria still the modal life form.",
          "cite": "Full House (1996), Part Four",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues apparent progress in evolution is variation spreading from a wall of minimal complexity, with no drive or direction.",
          "cite": "Full House (1996), Part Four 'The Modal Bacter: Why Progress Does not Rule the History of Life'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "dissents",
              "says": "Argues apparent progress is spread away from a wall of minimal complexity, with bacteria still the modal life form.",
              "cite": "Full House (1996), Part Four",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "ruse-1996-monad-to-man",
      "title": "Monad to Man: The Concept of Progress in Evolutionary Biology",
      "author": "Michael Ruse",
      "year": 1996,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.hup.harvard.edu/books/9780674032484",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/ruse-1996-monad-to-man",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that ideas of evolutionary progress drew on cultural ideas of Progress, and separates the two.",
          "cite": "Monad to Man (1996), whole book, per reviews",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "eller-2000-myth-of-matriarchal-prehistory",
      "title": "The Myth of Matriarchal Prehistory: Why an Invented Past Will Not Give Women a Future",
      "author": "Cynthia Eller",
      "year": 2000,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.beacon.org/The-Myth-of-Matriarchal-Prehistory-P363.aspx",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/eller-2000-myth-of-matriarchal-prehistory",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that the evidence does not show a peaceful, goddess-centred prehistory overturned by later invaders; addresses the lost-age reading of part (a).",
          "cite": "The Myth of Matriarchal Prehistory (2000), ch. 5 'Finding Gender in Prehistory' (p. 81), ch. 6 'The Case Against Prehistoric Matriarchies I: Other Societies, Early Societies' (p. 93), ch. 7 'The Case Against Prehistoric Matriarchies II: Prehistoric Art and Architecture' (p. 116) and ch. 8 'Was There a Patriarchal Revolution?' (p. 157)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "dundes-2005-folkloristics-twenty-first-century",
      "title": "Folkloristics in the Twenty-First Century (AFS Invited Presidential Plenary Address, 2004)",
      "author": "Alan Dundes",
      "year": 2005,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://muse.jhu.edu/article/188764/summary",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/dundes-2005-folkloristics-twenty-first-century",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects Campbell's universal hero pattern as built from selected and miscategorised tales; addresses the monomyth as a story every culture shares.",
          "cite": "Folkloristics in the Twenty-First Century (2005), pp. 394-399 (pages as given in the 2024 critique 'One myth to rule them all')",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "fischer-bidell-2006-dynamic-development",
      "title": "Dynamic Development of Action and Thought",
      "author": "Kurt W. Fischer; Thomas R. Bidell",
      "year": 2006,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470147658.chpsy0107",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/fischer-bidell-2006-dynamic-development",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Describes development as a web of skills varying with context, and makes no claim about each person taking part in a cosmic evolution.",
          "cite": "Dynamic Development of Action and Thought (2006), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Holds that lower skill levels stay available within a range set by context, a claim weaker than whole structures staying active.",
              "cite": "Dynamic Development of Action and Thought (2006), Handbook of Child Psychology, 6th edition, volume 1, ch. 7, pp. 313 to 399",
              "grade": "[TBV]",
              "readFrom": "abstract"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "meyerhoff-2010-bald-ambition",
      "title": "Bald Ambition: A Critique of Ken Wilber's Theory of Everything",
      "author": "Jeff Meyerhoff",
      "year": 2010,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.integralworld.net/meyerhoff-ba-1b.html",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/meyerhoff-2010-bald-ambition",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Disputes Wilber's holarchy as a neutral ranking of nature, arguing that its terms carry hidden value judgements.",
          "cite": "Bald Ambition (2010), ch. 1, section B",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "dissents",
              "says": "Disputes Wilber's holarchy as a neutral ranking of nature, arguing that its terms carry hidden value judgements.",
              "cite": "Bald Ambition (2010), ch. 1, section B",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "text"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C1",
              "position": "dissents",
              "says": "Argues that earlier wholes are often destroyed, as tribal and village life declines, so transcend and include fails as a law.",
              "cite": "Bald Ambition (2010), ch. 1, section B",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "text"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "sober-2012-remarkable-facts",
      "title": "Remarkable Facts: Ending Science as We Know It",
      "author": "Elliott Sober",
      "year": 2012,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.bostonreview.net/articles/remarkable-facts/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/sober-2012-remarkable-facts",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects Nagel's argument that nature needs goal-directed principles to explain the rise of life and mind.",
          "cite": "Boston Review (2012), section 'Brute Facts'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "corballis-2014-left-brain-right-brain",
      "title": "Left Brain, Right Brain: Facts and Fantasies",
      "author": "Michael C. Corballis",
      "year": 2014,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.1001767",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/corballis-2014-left-brain-right-brain",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C4",
              "position": "dissents",
              "says": "Holds that McGilchrist's reading of Western culture through the hemispheres reaches well past what the neurological evidence shows.",
              "cite": "Left Brain, Right Brain: Facts and Fantasies (2014)",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "text"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "butters-2015-brief-history-of-spiral-dynamics",
      "title": "A Brief History of Spiral Dynamics",
      "author": "Albion M. Butters",
      "year": 2015,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.30664/ar.67574",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/butters-2015-brief-history-of-spiral-dynamics",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C4",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Traces the first and second tiers to Graves's data and reports criticism of the tier hierarchy and the founders' disputes over it.",
              "cite": "A Brief History of Spiral Dynamics (2015), sections on Graves and on criticism",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "text"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "conrad-2019-big-history-project-colonizing-knowledges",
      "title": "The Big History Project and colonizing knowledges in world history curriculum",
      "author": "Jenni Conrad",
      "year": 2019,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00220272.2018.1493143",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/conrad-2019-big-history-project-colonizing-knowledges",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Reports that the Big History Project curriculum promotes Eurocentrism through its content and sources, marginalising non-European peoples and Indigenous knowledges.",
          "cite": "Journal of Curriculum Studies 51(1) (2019): 1-20, abstract; full text not read",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "arnold-2019-where-in-the-brain-does-buddhism-come-from",
      "title": "Where in the Brain Does Buddhism Come From? Critical Thoughts Regarding Iain McGilchrist's Reflections on Religion",
      "author": "Dan Arnold",
      "year": 2019,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1080/2153599X.2019.1604414",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/arnold-2019-where-in-the-brain-does-buddhism-come-from",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "C4",
              "position": "qualifies",
              "says": "Accepts McGilchrist's lateralization hypothesis as cogent but argues brain science cannot ground his verdicts on whole cultures and historical eras.",
              "cite": "Religion, Brain & Behavior 9(4): 345-362 (2019), sections 'Oriental culture and Indian Buddhism' and 'Whence McGilchrist's normative assessments?'",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "text"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "graeber-wengrow-2021-dawn-of-everything",
      "title": "The Dawn of Everything",
      "author": "David Graeber, David Wengrow",
      "year": 2021,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/graeber-wengrow-2021-dawn-of-everything",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Studies the forms of human social life and makes no claim about the universe.",
          "cite": "The Dawn of Everything (2021), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B2",
              "position": "dissents",
              "says": "Rejects evolutionary stages of society running from bands to states.",
              "cite": "The Dawn of Everything (2021), chs 1 and 2",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": [
            {
              "code": "B3",
              "position": "dissents",
              "says": "Argues people experimented with social forms in many directions, including seasonal switching.",
              "cite": "The Dawn of Everything (2021), chs 3 and 8",
              "grade": "[IC]",
              "readFrom": "review"
            }
          ]
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects the Garden of Eden story and any single transition while tracing gradual, uneven losses of three social freedoms, disputing part (a).",
          "cite": "The Dawn of Everything (Allen Lane, 2021), ch. 1 'Farewell to Humanity's Childhood', pp. 8-9 and 25; ch. 10 'Why the State Has No Origin', p. 426 (per Morris); ch. 12 'Conclusion', from p. 493",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "karst-2023-positive-citation-bias",
      "title": "Positive citation bias and overinterpreted results lead to misinformation on common mycorrhizal networks in forests",
      "author": "Justine Karst, Melanie D. Jones, Jason D. Hoeksema",
      "year": 2023,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-023-01986-1",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/karst-2023-positive-citation-bias",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "Assesses the field evidence on forest fungal networks, and makes no claim about human minds or a Noosphere.",
          "cite": "Nature Ecology & Evolution 7(4): 501-511 (2023), Perspective, abstract",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "martinon-torres-2024-no-evidence-naledi",
      "title": "No scientific evidence that Homo naledi buried their dead and produced rock art",
      "author": "María Martinón-Torres, Diego Garate, Andy I. R. Herries, Michael D. Petraglia",
      "year": 2024,
      "group": "9. Critics of the sequence",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/martinon-torres-2024-no-evidence-naledi",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "myers-1903-human-personality",
      "title": "Human Personality and Its Survival of Bodily Death",
      "author": "F. W. H. Myers",
      "year": 1903,
      "group": "10. Anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/38492",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/myers-1903-human-personality",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Argues that personality involves an element that survives bodily death, and that evidence from apparitions points to the action of departed spirits.",
          "cite": "Human Personality (abridged ed., Longmans, Green, 1906; Gutenberg text of the 1918 impression), ch. I 'Introduction', pp. 1, 9 and 13",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Holds that converging experimental and spontaneous evidence supports telepathy, communication from mind to mind without the recognised organs of sense.",
          "cite": "Human Personality (abridged 1906 ed.), ch. I, pp. 8-9; Glossary, 'Telepathy', p. xvii",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Argues that waking consciousness is a selection from a larger self, shown only partly through an organism not framed for its full expression.",
          "cite": "Human Personality (abridged 1906 ed.), ch. I, pp. 13, 15 and 18; ch. III 'Genius', p. 59",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "huxley-1954-doors-of-perception",
      "title": "The Doors of Perception",
      "author": "Aldous Huxley",
      "year": 1954,
      "group": "10. Anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/huxley-1954-doors-of-perception",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Proposes that the brain and nervous system form a reducing valve, admitting from a wider Mind at Large only what biological survival needs.",
          "cite": "The Doors of Perception (1954), the Mind at Large passage after Huxley's quotation of Broad, p. 12 of the 1994 edition cited in Webb (2023); pages not read",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "van-lommel-2001-near-death-experience-cardiac-arrest",
      "title": "Near-death experience in survivors of cardiac arrest: a prospective study in the Netherlands",
      "author": "Pim van Lommel; Ruud van Wees; Vincent Meyers; Ingrid Elfferich",
      "year": 2001,
      "group": "10. Anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(01)07100-8",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/van-lommel-2001-near-death-experience-cardiac-arrest",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Reports near-death experiences in 18% of 344 resuscitated cardiac arrest patients, unexplained by the measured medical factors; leaves open whether consciousness continues.",
          "cite": "The Lancet 358(9298): 2039-2045 (2001), abstract, Findings and Interpretation; pp. 2039 and 2043 as quoted in Braithwaite (2008)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "storm-tressoldi-di-risio-2010-meta-analysis-free-response",
      "title": "Meta-analysis of free-response studies, 1992-2008: Assessing the noise reduction model in parapsychology",
      "author": "Lance Storm; Patrizio E. Tressoldi; Lorenzo Di Risio",
      "year": 2010,
      "group": "10. Anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1037/a0019457",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/storm-tressoldi-di-risio-2010-meta-analysis-free-response",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Argues that pooled ganzfeld and other free-response studies show information transfer above chance.",
          "cite": "Psychological Bulletin 136(4) (2010), 471-485, abstract and conclusion",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "bem-2011-feeling-the-future",
      "title": "Feeling the Future: Experimental Evidence for Anomalous Retroactive Influences on Cognition and Affect",
      "author": "Daryl J. Bem",
      "year": 2011,
      "group": "10. Anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1037/a0021524",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/bem-2011-feeling-the-future",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Reports experiments in which later stimuli appear to influence earlier responses.",
          "cite": "JPSP 100(3), Experiments 1-9",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "mossbridge-tressoldi-utts-2012-predictive-physiological-anticipation",
      "title": "Predictive Physiological Anticipation Preceding Seemingly Unpredictable Stimuli: A Meta-Analysis",
      "author": "Julia Mossbridge; Patrizio Tressoldi; Jessica Utts",
      "year": 2012,
      "group": "10. Anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2012.00390",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/mossbridge-tressoldi-utts-2012-predictive-physiological-anticipation",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Reports body measures shifting before unpredictable stimuli in the direction of the later response.",
          "cite": "Frontiers in Psychology 3: 390, Results",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "parnia-2014-aware",
      "title": "AWARE—AWAreness during REsuscitation—A prospective study",
      "author": "Sam Parnia; Ken Spearpoint; Gabriele de Vos; Peter Fenwick; and colleagues",
      "year": 2014,
      "group": "10. Anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resuscitation.2014.09.004",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/parnia-2014-aware",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Reports one verified period of awareness during cardiac arrest, without showing that mind exists apart from the brain.",
          "cite": "Resuscitation 85(12), abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Reports one verifiable account of awareness, while no hidden visual target was identified.",
          "cite": "Resuscitation 85(12), abstract and Results",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "cardena-2018-experimental-evidence-psi",
      "title": "The Experimental Evidence for Parapsychological Phenomena: A Review",
      "author": "Etzel Cardeña",
      "year": 2018,
      "group": "10. Anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000236",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/cardena-2018-experimental-evidence-psi",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Argues that experimental psi evidence is comparable to that for established phenomena.",
          "cite": "American Psychologist 73(5), abstract, p. 663",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "mashour-2019-paradoxical-lucidity",
      "title": "Paradoxical Lucidity: A Potential Paradigm Shift for the Neurobiology and Treatment of Severe Dementias",
      "author": "George A. Mashour; Lori Frank; Alexander Batthyany; Ann Marie Kolanowski; Michael Nahm; Dena Schulman-Green; Bruce Greyson; Serguei Pakhomov; Jason Karlawish; Raj C. Shah",
      "year": 2019,
      "group": "10. Anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jalz.2019.04.002",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/mashour-2019-paradoxical-lucidity",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Reports unexpected lucidity in severe dementia and seeks neurobiological explanations, with no claim of survival.",
          "cite": "Alzheimer's & Dementia 15(8) (2019), Introduction",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "parnia-2023-aware-ii",
      "title": "AWAreness during REsuscitation - II: A Multi-Center Study of Consciousness and Awareness in Cardiac Arrest",
      "author": "Sam Parnia; Tara Keshavarz Shirazi; Jignesh Patel; and colleagues",
      "year": 2023,
      "group": "10. Anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resuscitation.2023.109903",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/parnia-2023-aware-ii",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Reports lucid recalled experiences of death during CPR, without showing that mind exists apart from the brain.",
          "cite": "Resuscitation 191: 109903, Results",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Reports that no interviewed survivor identified the visual image and 1 of 28 identified the auditory stimulus.",
          "cite": "Resuscitation 191: 109903, abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "dickens-2024-telepathy-tapes",
      "title": "The Telepathy Tapes",
      "author": "Ky Dickens",
      "year": 2024,
      "group": "10. Anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://thetelepathytapes.com",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/dickens-2024-telepathy-tapes",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Presents demonstrations offered as evidence that some nonspeaking autistic people receive information telepathically.",
          "cite": "The Telepathy Tapes, season 1 (September to December 2024)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "weiler-woollacott-2025-rethinking-communication-and-consciousness",
      "title": "Rethinking communication and consciousness: Lessons from the telepathy tapes podcast",
      "author": "Marina Weiler; Marjorie Woollacott",
      "year": 2025,
      "group": "10. Anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1550830725001624",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/weiler-woollacott-2025-rethinking-communication-and-consciousness",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that anecdotes of possibly telepathic communication warrant controlled experiments; does not claim telepathy is shown.",
          "cite": "Explore 21(6): 103271 (2025), abstract and 'Moving forward' section",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "lamont-1935-illusion-of-immortality",
      "title": "The Illusion of Immortality",
      "author": "Corliss Lamont",
      "year": 1935,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Illusion_of_Immortality.html?id=UQtaAAAAYAAJ",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/lamont-1935-illusion-of-immortality",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that personality depends on the body and brain, so that survival of bodily death is very improbable.",
          "cite": "The Illusion of Immortality (1935), ch. 'The Verdict of Science' (p. 58 in the 1935 Putnam printing, per Google Books contents); memory's dependence on the brain argued at p. 76 of the 1990 Ungar/Continuum edition, as quoted by Augustine",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects William James's transmission analogy, holding that the evidence shows the mind depends on the brain.",
          "cite": "The Illusion of Immortality, 1990 Ungar/Continuum edition, pp. 98-104 (the brain as instrument or transmitter of the soul, with the colored-glass reply at p. 104), as quoted by Augustine; chapter not confirmed",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "edwards-1992-immortality",
      "title": "Immortality",
      "author": "Paul Edwards (ed.)",
      "year": 1992,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://infidels.org/kiosk/book/immortality/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/edwards-1992-immortality",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that the evidence that brain states cause conscious states is as strong as for accepted physical causes, which tells against survival.",
          "cite": "Immortality (1992), selection 33, Edwards, 'The Dependence of Consciousness on the Brain', pp. 292-307, esp. p. 294 (as quoted in Augustine)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Holds that particular brain states bring about particular conscious states, a production claim at odds with the filter view.",
          "cite": "Immortality (1992), selection 33, pp. 292-307, esp. p. 296, placed directly after selection 32, James, 'Consciousness, the Brain and Immortality' (whether Edwards names James was not checked)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "edwards-1996-reincarnation-critical-examination",
      "title": "Reincarnation: A Critical Examination",
      "author": "Paul Edwards",
      "year": 1996,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://archive.org/details/reincarnationcri0000edwa",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/edwards-1996-reincarnation-critical-examination",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that reincarnation needs a surviving carrier of memory and that no such carrier is credible.",
          "cite": "Reincarnation (1996), chapters 'The Astral Body' and 'Telephone Calls from the Dead, Birth Marks, and the Modus Operandi Problem' (the modus operandi argument at pp. 139-40, per Matlock)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that Stevenson's reincarnation cases rest on flawed investigation and have ordinary explanations, drawing on Champe Ransom's critique of his methods.",
          "cite": "Reincarnation (1996), the chapter on Dr. Ian Stevenson, the 'Galileo of Reincarnation', and those following, esp. pp. 255, 271 and 275-77",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "hyman-2010-meta-analysis-conceals",
      "title": "Meta-Analysis That Conceals More Than It Reveals: Comment on Storm et al. (2010)",
      "author": "Ray Hyman",
      "year": 2010,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1037/a0019676",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/hyman-2010-meta-analysis-conceals",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that the meta-analysis does not show psi evidence to be consistent or reliable, and that ganzfeld results lack independent replication.",
          "cite": "Psychological Bulletin 136(4) (2010), abstract, p. 486",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "wagenmakers-2011-why-psychologists-must-change",
      "title": "Why Psychologists Must Change the Way They Analyze Their Data: The Case of Psi: Comment on Bem (2011)",
      "author": "Eric-Jan Wagenmakers; Ruud Wetzels; Denny Borsboom; Han L. J. van der Maas",
      "year": 2011,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1037/a0022790",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/wagenmakers-2011-why-psychologists-must-change",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that Bem's statistics overstate the evidence for precognition.",
          "cite": "JPSP 100(3): 426-432",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "ritchie-wiseman-french-2012-failing-the-future",
      "title": "Failing the Future: Three Unsuccessful Attempts to Replicate Bem's 'Retroactive Facilitation of Recall' Effect",
      "author": "Stuart J. Ritchie; Richard Wiseman; Christopher C. French",
      "year": 2012,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0033423",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/ritchie-wiseman-french-2012-failing-the-future",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Reports three failed replications of Bem's retroactive recall effect.",
          "cite": "PLoS ONE 7(3): e33423, Results",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "rouder-morey-province-2013-bayes-factor-meta-analysis",
      "title": "A Bayes Factor Meta-Analysis of Recent Extrasensory Perception Experiments: Comment on Storm, Tressoldi, and Di Risio (2010)",
      "author": "Jeffrey N. Rouder; Richard D. Morey; Jordan M. Province",
      "year": 2013,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1037/a0029008",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/rouder-morey-province-2013-bayes-factor-meta-analysis",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Grants that the free-response data favour an effect as presented, and argues that corrections to the data set shrink that support sharply.",
          "cite": "Psychological Bulletin 139(1) (2013), abstract, p. 241",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "schlosser-2014-facilitated-communication-authorship",
      "title": "Facilitated Communication and Authorship: A Systematic Review",
      "author": "Ralf W. Schlosser; Susan Balandin; Bronwyn Hemsley; Teresa Iacono; Paul Probst; Stephen von Tetzchner",
      "year": 2014,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.3109/07434618.2014.971490",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/schlosser-2014-facilitated-communication-authorship",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that facilitators author FC messages, an ordinary source for information the step attributes to other channels.",
          "cite": "Augmentative and Alternative Communication 30(4) (2014), abstract and results",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "augustine-martin-2015-myth-of-an-afterlife",
      "title": "The Myth of an Afterlife: The Case against Life After Death",
      "author": "Keith Augustine; Michael Martin",
      "year": 2015,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/augustine-martin-2015-myth-of-an-afterlife",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that brain damage and brain death end mental life, so consciousness does not exist beyond the body.",
          "cite": "The Myth of an Afterlife (2015), Part I, 'Empirical Arguments for Annihilation'",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that neuroscience shows a functioning brain is necessary, and sufficient, for consciousness, which leaves a separate soul no work to do.",
          "cite": "The Myth of an Afterlife (2015), Augustine and Fishman, 'The Dualist's Dilemma: The High Cost of Reconciling Neuroscience with a Soul', pp. 203-292, the last chapter of Part I; chapter number not confirmed",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "asha-2018-facilitated-communication",
      "title": "Facilitated Communication [Position Statement]",
      "author": "American Speech-Language-Hearing Association",
      "year": 2018,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.asha.org/policy/ps2018-00352/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/asha-2018-facilitated-communication",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that facilitated messages come from the facilitator, a known channel, and says nothing on telepathy.",
          "cite": "ASHA PS2018-00352",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "hemsley-2018-systematic-review-facilitated-communication",
      "title": "Systematic review of facilitated communication 2014-2018 finds no new evidence that messages delivered using facilitated communication are authored by the person with disability",
      "author": "Bronwyn Hemsley; Lucy Bryant; Ralf W. Schlosser; Howard C. Shane; Russell Lang; Diane Paul; Meher Banajee; Marie Ireland",
      "year": 2018,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1177/2396941518821570",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/hemsley-2018-systematic-review-facilitated-communication",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Finds no evidence that FC users author their messages, leaving the facilitator as the likely source of content.",
          "cite": "Autism & Developmental Language Impairments 3 (2018), 1-8, abstract and conclusion",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "reber-alcock-2020-searching-for-the-impossible",
      "title": "Searching for the Impossible: Parapsychology's Elusive Quest",
      "author": "Arthur S. Reber; James E. Alcock",
      "year": 2020,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000486",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/reber-alcock-2020-searching-for-the-impossible",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that psi data reflect method, analysis or chance, because psi would break scientific principles.",
          "cite": "American Psychologist 75(3), abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "asat-2025-responds-to-telepathy-tapes-review",
      "title": "ASAT Responds to The Skeptical Inquirer: 'The Telepathy Tapes: A Dangerous Cornucopia of Pseudoscience'",
      "author": "Association for Science in Autism Treatment",
      "year": 2025,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://asatonline.org/media_watch/asat-responds-to-the-skeptical-inquirer-the-telepathy-tapes-a-dangerous-cornucopia-of-pseudoscience/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/asat-2025-responds-to-telepathy-tapes-review",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects the podcast's claims of paranormal abilities in nonspeaking autistic people and of authentic authorship through facilitated communication, urging listeners to question them.",
          "cite": "ASAT Responds to The Skeptical Inquirer (27 January 2025), statement text",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "vyse-2025-telepathy-tapes",
      "title": "The Telepathy Tapes: A Dangerous Cornucopia of Pseudoscience",
      "author": "Stuart Vyse",
      "year": 2025,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://skepticalinquirer.org/exclusive/the-telepathy-tapes-a-dangerous-cornucopia-of-pseudoscience/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/vyse-2025-telepathy-tapes",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that controlled tests show facilitators authoring the messages the podcast treats as telepathic.",
          "cite": "Skeptical Inquirer, 6 January 2025",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "boynton-2026-debunking-telepathy-tapes",
      "title": "Debunking The Telepathy Tapes: The Role of Facilitator Behaviors",
      "author": "Janyce L. Boynton",
      "year": 2026,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://skepticalinquirer.org/2026/08/debunking-the-telepathy-tapes-the-role-of-facilitator-behaviors/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/boynton-2026-debunking-telepathy-tapes",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that the podcast's apparent telepathy is explained by facilitator cueing during letter selection.",
          "cite": "Skeptical Inquirer 50(5) (2026), opening sections",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "hupp-2026-how-the-telepathy-tapes-silences-voices",
      "title": "How The Telepathy Tapes Silences Voices",
      "author": "Stephen Hupp",
      "year": 2026,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://skepticalinquirer.org/2026/08/how-the-telepathy-tapes-silences-voices/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/hupp-2026-how-the-telepathy-tapes-silences-voices",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Holds that The Telepathy Tapes popularizes facilitated communication, a method debunked decades ago, and that such methods silence people with limited communication.",
          "cite": "Skeptical Inquirer 50(5), September/October 2026, 'From the Editor'; T2 dissent inferred from its rejection of the method that produced the podcast's messages (inference)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "delgado-ron-2026-response-to-weiler-and-woollacott",
      "title": "Response to Weiler and Woollacott, 2025",
      "author": "Jorge Andrés Delgado-Ron",
      "year": 2026,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41855616/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/delgado-ron-2026-response-to-weiler-and-woollacott",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that the controlled studies the paper cites traced messages to prompts seen only by helpers.",
          "cite": "Explore 22(3): 103387 (2026), a letter with no abstract; the passage is known from one quoted excerpt",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "review",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "beals-2026-telepathy-via-facilitated-communication",
      "title": "Telepathy via Facilitated Communication in Profound Autism: A 21st Century Delusion",
      "author": "Katharine Beals",
      "year": 2026,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://skepticalinquirer.org/2026/08/telepathy-via-facilitated-communication-in-profound-autism-a-21st-century-delusion/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/beals-2026-telepathy-via-facilitated-communication",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that reported autism telepathy arrives through facilitated communication, a pseudoscientific technique whose users respond to subtle facilitator cues.",
          "cite": "Skeptical Inquirer 50(5), September/October 2026, sections 'The Inevitable Belief in Facilitated Communication' and 'Why Widespread Belief in Autism Telepathy Is Inevitable'",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "des-roches-rosa-2026-telepathy-tapes-hot-mess",
      "title": "The Telepathy Tapes Is Such A Hot Mess",
      "author": "Shannon Des Roches Rosa",
      "year": 2026,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://thinkingautismguide.com/2026/02/the-telepathy-tapes-is-such-a-hot-mess.html",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/des-roches-rosa-2026-telepathy-tapes-hot-mess",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Treats the telepathy claims as doubtful at best and offers sensitivity to nonverbal cues as the likelier account.",
          "cite": "The Telepathy Tapes Is Such A Hot Mess (9 February 2026)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "vyse-2026-portal-into-world-of-woo",
      "title": "The Telepathy Tapes: A Portal into a World of Woo",
      "author": "Stuart Vyse",
      "year": 2026,
      "group": "11. Critics of the anomalous experience research",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://stuartvyse.com/2026/08/18/my-first-cover-story-my-csicon-talk/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/vyse-2026-portal-into-world-of-woo",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects the paranormal claims of the podcast's second season, which he reports as dropping its earlier guardrails.",
          "cite": "Skeptical Inquirer 50(5), September/October 2026, section 'Beyond Season One'; the author's description of the article",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "meadows-limits-to-growth",
      "title": "The Limits to Growth",
      "author": "Donella H. Meadows, Dennis L. Meadows, Jørgen Randers, William W. Behrens III",
      "year": 1972,
      "group": "12. Growth curves and limits",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/meadows-limits-to-growth",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Models overshoot and collapse of material growth on a finite planet, with no claim about consciousness or a Noosphere.",
          "cite": "The Limits to Growth (1972), ch. III 'Growth in the World System' (p. 88), with the standard run's collapse at p. 125, and ch. IV 'Technology and the Limits to Growth' (p. 129)",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "tainter-collapse-complex-societies",
      "title": "The Collapse of Complex Societies",
      "author": "Joseph A. Tainter",
      "year": 1988,
      "group": "12. Growth curves and limits",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/collapse-of-complex-societies/85D9A1BD3F5D8D9A82D74FE5F84A8E5B",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/tainter-collapse-complex-societies",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Argues added complexity yields declining marginal returns until collapse, with no claim about consciousness or a Noosphere.",
          "cite": "The Collapse of Complex Societies (1988), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "modis-2002-forecasting-growth-complexity",
      "title": "Forecasting the Growth of Complexity and Change",
      "author": "Theodore Modis",
      "year": 2002,
      "group": "12. Growth curves and limits",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1016/S0040-1625(01)00172-X",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/modis-2002-forecasting-growth-complexity",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Fits a logistic curve to complexity across history and makes no link to a split in consciousness.",
          "cite": "Technological Forecasting and Social Change 69(4) (2002), 377-404, abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Forecasts that the growth of complexity and change is about to slow, with no Noosphere claim.",
          "cite": "Technological Forecasting and Social Change 69(4) (2002), 377-404, abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "perez-2002-technological-revolutions",
      "title": "Technological Revolutions and Financial Capital: The Dynamics of Bubbles and Golden Ages",
      "author": "Carlota Perez",
      "year": 2002,
      "group": "12. Growth curves and limits",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/perez-2002-technological-revolutions",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Describes surges of technology and finance within the industrial era, bearing loosely on part (c), the growth curve.",
          "cite": "Technological Revolutions and Financial Capital (2002), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "smil-2019-growth",
      "title": "Growth: From Microorganisms to Megacities",
      "author": "Vaclav Smil",
      "year": 2019,
      "group": "12. Growth curves and limits",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/smil-2019-growth",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Documents the rise and slowdown of empires and civilisations, and fits a logistic to Roman territory, without linking either to consciousness.",
          "cite": "Growth (2019), ch. 5, 'Populations, Societies, Economies', sections 'Empires' (p. 357) and 'Civilizations' (p. 436)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Warns against forecasting a system's position on a logistic curve from how well past data fit it.",
          "cite": "Growth (2019), ch. 1, 'Trajectories: or common patterns of growth', section 'Confined Growth Patterns' (p. 31)",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "summary",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "korotayev-2020-twenty-first-century-singularity",
      "title": "The Twenty-First-Century Singularity in the Big History Perspective: A Re-analysis",
      "author": "Andrey V. Korotayev",
      "year": 2020,
      "group": "12. Growth curves and limits",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-030-33730-8_2",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/korotayev-2020-twenty-first-century-singularity",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Documents accelerating growth of complexity on Earth and stays silent on any striving behind it.",
          "cite": "The 21st Century Singularity and Global Futures (2020), ch. 2, pp. 19-75",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Fits the long macroevolutionary series to a singularity near 2027 to 2029, read as an inflection point before long-term slowdown; no Noosphere.",
          "cite": "The 21st Century Singularity and Global Futures (2020), ch. 2, pp. 19-75",
          "grade": "[TBV]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "alexander-1990-bioregionalism-science-or-sensibility",
      "title": "Bioregionalism: Science or Sensibility?",
      "author": "Donald Alexander",
      "year": 1990,
      "group": "13. Place and bioregionalism",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.5840/enviroethics199012217",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/alexander-1990-bioregionalism-science-or-sensibility",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that bioregional writing mystifies the region and leans toward a 'nature knows best' view.",
          "cite": "Environmental Ethics 12(2), abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "agrawal-1995-dismantling-the-divide",
      "title": "Dismantling the Divide Between Indigenous and Scientific Knowledge",
      "author": "Arun Agrawal",
      "year": 1995,
      "group": "13. Place and bioregionalism",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-7660.1995.tb00560.x",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/agrawal-1995-dismantling-the-divide",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Argues that no fixed line divides indigenous and scientific knowledge, which recasts the two streams T9 sees flowing together.",
          "cite": "Development and Change 26(3) (1995), 413-439, abstract and conclusion",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "nadasdy-1999-politics-of-tek",
      "title": "The Politics of TEK: Power and the \"Integration\" of Knowledge",
      "author": "Paul Nadasdy",
      "year": 1999,
      "group": "13. Place and bioregionalism",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://www.jstor.org/stable/40316502",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/nadasdy-1999-politics-of-tek",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that joining traditional knowledge to science forces it into bureaucratic forms and moves power away from its holders.",
          "cite": "Arctic Anthropology 36(1-2) (1999), 1-18, abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "dst-2004-indigenous-knowledge-systems-policy",
      "title": "Indigenous Knowledge Systems Policy",
      "author": "Department of Science and Technology, Republic of South Africa",
      "year": 2004,
      "group": "13. Place and bioregionalism",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://pmg.org.za/committee-meeting/23085/",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/dst-2004-indigenous-knowledge-systems-policy",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Affirms indigenous knowledge as living systems held by practitioners, and is silent on any split.",
          "cite": "IKS Policy (2004), policy drivers",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Holds that indigenous knowledge should interface with other knowledge systems, at national scale.",
          "cite": "IKS Policy (2004), driver 4",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "purcell-brown-2005-against-the-local-trap",
      "title": "Against the Local Trap: Scale and the Study of Environment and Development",
      "author": "Mark Purcell; J. Christopher Brown",
      "year": 2005,
      "group": "13. Place and bioregionalism",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1191/1464993405ps122oa",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/purcell-brown-2005-against-the-local-trap",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Rejects the assumption that local arrangements are inherently more just or sustainable.",
          "cite": "Progress in Development Studies 5(4), abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "bartlett-marshall-marshall-2012-two-eyed-seeing",
      "title": "Two-Eyed Seeing and Other Lessons Learned within a Co-Learning Journey of Bringing Together Indigenous and Mainstream Knowledges and Ways of Knowing",
      "author": "Cheryl Bartlett; Murdena Marshall; Albert Marshall",
      "year": 2012,
      "group": "13. Place and bioregionalism",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s13412-012-0086-8",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/bartlett-marshall-marshall-2012-two-eyed-seeing",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Argues that Indigenous and mainstream knowledges should be brought together through co-learning, each kept whole.",
          "cite": "J Environ Stud Sci 2(4), lessons learned",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "kimmerer-2013-braiding-sweetgrass",
      "title": "Braiding Sweetgrass",
      "author": "Robin Wall Kimmerer",
      "year": 2013,
      "group": "13. Place and bioregionalism",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": null,
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/kimmerer-2013-braiding-sweetgrass",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Argues, as a Potawatomi botanist, for braiding Indigenous and scientific ways of knowing.",
          "cite": "Braiding Sweetgrass (2013), chapter not checked",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "wright-2019-two-eyed-seeing-integrative-review",
      "title": "Using Two-Eyed Seeing in Research With Indigenous People: An Integrative Review",
      "author": "Amy L. Wright; Chelsea Gabel; Marilyn Ballantyne; Susan M. Jack; Olive Wahoush",
      "year": 2019,
      "group": "13. Place and bioregionalism",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1177/1609406919869695",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/wright-2019-two-eyed-seeing-integrative-review",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Reports that research applying Two-Eyed Seeing describes the joining of knowledges vaguely.",
          "cite": "IJQM 18, abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "reid-2021-two-eyed-seeing-fisheries",
      "title": "\"Two-Eyed Seeing\": An Indigenous Framework to Transform Fisheries Research and Management",
      "author": "Andrea J. Reid; Lauren E. Eckert; John-Francis Lane; Nathan Young; Scott G. Hinch; Chris T. Darimont; Steven J. Cooke; Natalie C. Ban; Albert Marshall",
      "year": 2021,
      "group": "13. Place and bioregionalism",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1111/faf.12516",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/reid-2021-two-eyed-seeing-fisheries",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "affirms",
          "says": "Argues that Indigenous and Western knowledges should guide fisheries together, without assimilating one into the other.",
          "cite": "Fish and Fisheries 22(2), abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "broadhead-howard-2021-confronting-contradictions",
      "title": "Confronting the Contradictions between Western and Indigenous Science: A Critical Perspective on Two-Eyed Seeing",
      "author": "Lee-Anne Broadhead; Sean Howard",
      "year": 2021,
      "group": "13. Place and bioregionalism",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1177/1177180121996326",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/broadhead-howard-2021-confronting-contradictions",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "dissents",
          "says": "Argues that some Indigenous and Eurocentric approaches contradict each other and cannot be combined.",
          "cite": "AlterNative 17(1), abstract",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "abstract",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "slug": "roher-2021-etuaptmumk-scoping-review",
      "title": "How is Etuaptmumk/Two-Eyed Seeing Characterized in Indigenous Health Research? A Scoping Review",
      "author": "Sophie I. G. Roher; Ziwa Yu; Debbie H. Martin; Anita C. Benoit",
      "year": 2021,
      "group": "13. Place and bioregionalism",
      "seedList": false,
      "link": "https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0254612",
      "wikiUrl": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/sources/roher-2021-etuaptmumk-scoping-review",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "cells": {
        "T1": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T2": {
          "position": null,
          "basis": "pending",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T3": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "H",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T4": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T5": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "B1",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T6": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C2",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T7": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "A3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T8": {
          "position": "silent",
          "says": "",
          "cite": "",
          "grade": "",
          "readFrom": "",
          "basis": "inherited",
          "from": "C3",
          "secondary": []
        },
        "T9": {
          "position": "qualifies",
          "says": "Reports that Two-Eyed Seeing keeps knowledge systems distinct and that later authors misdescribe it as blending.",
          "cite": "PLOS ONE 16(7), Discussion",
          "grade": "[IC]",
          "readFrom": "text",
          "basis": "checked",
          "secondary": []
        }
      }
    }
  ],
  "dates": [
    {
      "slug": "berger-naledi-mortuary-practice",
      "title": "Berger et al.: mortuary practice by Homo naledi",
      "source": "Berger et al., deliberate burial by Homo naledi (2025)",
      "sourceSlug": "berger-2025-deliberate-burial-homo-naledi",
      "threshold": "mortuary practice by Homo naledi",
      "structure": "none",
      "structureOrder": 0,
      "dateGiven": "Dinaledi remains about 236,000 to 335,000 years old [TBV]",
      "yearsAgo": 335000,
      "basis": "Burial features in the Rising Star cave system",
      "recordCheck": "Contested by Martinón-Torres et al. (2023 to 2024); eLife reviewers split [IC]",
      "fit": "earlier",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/berger-naledi-mortuary-practice"
    },
    {
      "slug": "donald-episodic-culture",
      "title": "Merlin Donald: episodic culture",
      "source": "Merlin Donald, Origins of the Modern Mind (1991)",
      "sourceSlug": "donald-1991-origins-of-the-modern-mind",
      "threshold": "episodic culture",
      "structure": "none",
      "structureOrder": 0,
      "dateGiven": "primate baseline",
      "yearsAgo": null,
      "basis": "Comparative primate cognition",
      "recordCheck": "Not a dated threshold",
      "fit": "not-comparable",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/donald-episodic-culture"
    },
    {
      "slug": "martinon-torres-earliest-burial",
      "title": "Martinón-Torres et al.: earliest cultural burial",
      "source": "Martinón-Torres et al., no evidence that Homo naledi buried its dead (2024)",
      "sourceSlug": "martinon-torres-2024-no-evidence-naledi",
      "threshold": "earliest cultural burial",
      "structure": "none",
      "structureOrder": 0,
      "dateGiven": "rejects the Homo naledi burial claim",
      "yearsAgo": null,
      "basis": "Taphonomy and sediment analysis",
      "recordCheck": "Earliest secure Homo sapiens burial in Africa about 78,000 years ago [TBV]",
      "fit": "not-comparable",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/martinon-torres-earliest-burial"
    },
    {
      "slug": "glossary-mimetic",
      "title": "Framer OS glossary: Mimetic",
      "source": "Michael Haupt, Framer OS and Crisis Codes Glossary (Google Drive, 10 December 2025)",
      "sourceSlug": null,
      "threshold": "Mimetic",
      "structure": "Mimetic",
      "structureOrder": 1,
      "dateGiven": "3.5 to 1.9 million years ago",
      "yearsAgo": 3500000,
      "basis": "Framer OS and Crisis Codes Glossary [MS]",
      "recordCheck": "Lomekwi 3 tools 3.3 million years ago (Harmand et al. 2015); Homo erectus appears near the 1.9 million end of the range [TBV]",
      "fit": "earlier",
      "grade": "[MS]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/glossary-mimetic"
    },
    {
      "slug": "working-page-mimetic",
      "title": "Working page: Mimetic Consciousness",
      "source": "Michael Haupt's working page, Evolution of Consciousness (Roam)",
      "sourceSlug": null,
      "threshold": "Mimetic Consciousness",
      "structure": "Mimetic",
      "structureOrder": 1,
      "dateGiven": "about 3.5 million years ago",
      "yearsAgo": 3500000,
      "basis": "First hominins described from Africa; basic tool use [MS]",
      "recordCheck": "Oldest known stone tools, 3.3 million years ago at Lomekwi 3, Kenya (Harmand et al. 2015, Nature 521); earliest Homo fossils about 2.8 million years ago [IC]",
      "fit": "earlier",
      "grade": "[MS]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/working-page-mimetic"
    },
    {
      "slug": "briggs-survival-magical-mythical",
      "title": "Roger Briggs: Mimetic",
      "source": "Roger Briggs, Emerging World (2021)",
      "sourceSlug": "briggs-2021-emerging-world",
      "threshold": "Mimetic",
      "structure": "Mimetic",
      "structureOrder": 1,
      "dateGiven": "starting about 3 million years ago, with the first manufactured stone tools",
      "yearsAgo": 3000000,
      "basis": "Emerging World, ch. 4, pp. 121, 123-124, 152: the first manufactured stone tools mark the mimetic revolution [TBV]",
      "recordCheck": "Oldest known stone tools, 3.3 million years ago at Lomekwi 3, Kenya (Harmand et al. 2015, Nature 521); earliest Homo fossils about 2.8 million years ago [IC]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/briggs-survival-magical-mythical"
    },
    {
      "slug": "donald-mimetic-culture",
      "title": "Merlin Donald: mimetic culture",
      "source": "Merlin Donald, Origins of the Modern Mind (1991)",
      "sourceSlug": "donald-1991-origins-of-the-modern-mind",
      "threshold": "mimetic culture",
      "structure": "Mimetic",
      "structureOrder": 1,
      "dateGiven": "near the speciation of Homo erectus, about 1.5 million years ago (Précis, 1993); secondary summaries say about 2 million",
      "yearsAgo": 1500000,
      "basis": "Brain size and the Homo erectus tool and dispersal record",
      "recordCheck": "Homo erectus from about 1.9 million years ago [TBV]; Wonderwerk fire 1.07 to 1.79 million years ago (Marin-Monfort et al. 2026)",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/donald-mimetic-culture"
    },
    {
      "slug": "beck-cowan-first-level",
      "title": "Beck and Cowan: first level of existence (Beige)",
      "source": "Beck and Cowan, Spiral Dynamics (1996)",
      "sourceSlug": "beck-cowan-spiral-dynamics",
      "threshold": "first level of existence (Beige)",
      "structure": "Mimetic",
      "structureOrder": 1,
      "dateGiven": "about 100,000 BCE (secondary summary) [TBV]",
      "yearsAgo": 100000,
      "basis": "Graves's levels",
      "recordCheck": "Hominin foraging lifeways are far older; Lomekwi 3 tools 3.3 million years ago (Harmand et al. 2015) [IC]",
      "fit": "later",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/beck-cowan-first-level"
    },
    {
      "slug": "gebser-archaic-magic-mythical",
      "title": "Jean Gebser: archaic, magic and mythical structures",
      "source": "Jean Gebser, The Ever-Present Origin",
      "sourceSlug": "gebser-ever-present-origin",
      "threshold": "archaic, magic and mythical structures",
      "structure": "Mimetic",
      "structureOrder": 1,
      "dateGiven": "undated or loosely dated",
      "yearsAgo": null,
      "basis": "Art, myth and language",
      "recordCheck": "No published dating tested against the record",
      "fit": "undated",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/gebser-archaic-magic-mythical"
    },
    {
      "slug": "briggs-magical",
      "title": "Roger Briggs: Magical",
      "source": "Roger Briggs, Emerging World (2021)",
      "sourceSlug": "briggs-2021-emerging-world",
      "threshold": "Magical",
      "structure": "Magical",
      "structureOrder": 2,
      "dateGiven": "starting about 1 million years ago",
      "yearsAgo": 1000000,
      "basis": "Emerging World, ch. 4, pp. 127-128, 152, 154: no marker in the tool industries; he ties the stage to Homo heidelbergensis, a large-brained species appearing about one million years ago [TBV]",
      "recordCheck": "Controlled fire about 1 million years ago at Wonderwerk Cave (Berna et al. 2012, PNAS); burnt bone dated 1.07 to 1.79 million years ago at Wonderwerk (Marin-Monfort et al. 2026, PLOS One) [IC]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/briggs-magical"
    },
    {
      "slug": "working-page-magical",
      "title": "Working page: Magical Consciousness",
      "source": "Michael Haupt's working page, Evolution of Consciousness (Roam)",
      "sourceSlug": null,
      "threshold": "Magical Consciousness",
      "structure": "Magical",
      "structureOrder": 2,
      "dateGiven": "about 1 million years ago",
      "yearsAgo": 1000000,
      "basis": "Homo erectus, Homo heidelbergensis and the Neanderthals; fire; animism [MS]",
      "recordCheck": "Controlled fire about 1 million years ago at Wonderwerk Cave (Berna et al. 2012, PNAS); burnt bone dated 1.07 to 1.79 million years ago at Wonderwerk (Marin-Monfort et al. 2026, PLOS One) [IC]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[MS]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/working-page-magical"
    },
    {
      "slug": "met-page-first-transitions",
      "title": "MET page: First three transitions, Mimetic through to Material",
      "source": "Major Evolutionary Transitions (wiki concept page)",
      "sourceSlug": null,
      "threshold": "First three transitions, Mimetic through to Material",
      "structure": "Magical",
      "structureOrder": 2,
      "dateGiven": "within the last 12,000 years (the page maps the first three transitions onto the growth curve since the Neolithic Revolution)",
      "yearsAgo": 12000,
      "basis": "The page's S-curve mapping [MS]; the date is a reading of that mapping (inference)",
      "recordCheck": "Controlled fire about 1 million years ago at Wonderwerk (Berna et al. 2012); symbolic behaviour from about 164,000 years ago (Marean et al. 2007) [IC]",
      "fit": "later",
      "grade": "[MS]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/met-page-first-transitions"
    },
    {
      "slug": "wilber-magic-mythic-rational",
      "title": "Ken Wilber: magic, mythic and rational stages (after Gebser)",
      "source": "Ken Wilber, Integral Psychology (2000)",
      "sourceSlug": "wilber-2000-integral-psychology",
      "threshold": "magic, mythic and rational stages (after Gebser)",
      "structure": "Magical",
      "structureOrder": 2,
      "dateGiven": "dated in Up from Eden (1981), not checked [TBV]",
      "yearsAgo": null,
      "basis": "Gebser and anthropological sources",
      "recordCheck": "Not checked",
      "fit": "undated",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/wilber-magic-mythic-rational"
    },
    {
      "slug": "donald-mythic-culture",
      "title": "Merlin Donald: mythic culture",
      "source": "Merlin Donald, Origins of the Modern Mind (1991)",
      "sourceSlug": "donald-1991-origins-of-the-modern-mind",
      "threshold": "mythic culture",
      "structure": "Mythic",
      "structureOrder": 3,
      "dateGiven": "with archaic Homo sapiens, about 300,000 years ago (Précis, 1993); about 200,000 years in one summary",
      "yearsAgo": 300000,
      "basis": "Spoken language and narrative",
      "recordCheck": "Pinnacle Point pigment about 164,000 years ago (Marean et al. 2007) [IC]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/donald-mythic-culture"
    },
    {
      "slug": "glossary-mythic",
      "title": "Framer OS glossary: Mythic",
      "source": "Michael Haupt, Framer OS and Crisis Codes Glossary (Google Drive, 10 December 2025)",
      "sourceSlug": null,
      "threshold": "Mythic",
      "structure": "Mythic",
      "structureOrder": 3,
      "dateGiven": "100,000 to 70,000 years ago",
      "yearsAgo": 100000,
      "basis": "Framer OS and Crisis Codes Glossary; an older document gives about 60,000 years ago [MS]",
      "recordCheck": "Pinnacle Point pigment about 164,000 years ago (Marean et al. 2007) [IC]",
      "fit": "later",
      "grade": "[MS]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/glossary-mythic"
    },
    {
      "slug": "henshilwood-abstract-drawing",
      "title": "Henshilwood et al.: abstract drawing",
      "source": "Henshilwood et al., Blombos Cave drawing (2018)",
      "sourceSlug": "henshilwood-2018-abstract-drawing-blombos",
      "threshold": "abstract drawing",
      "structure": "Mythic",
      "structureOrder": 3,
      "dateGiven": "about 73,000 years ago",
      "yearsAgo": 73000,
      "basis": "Dated Still Bay levels at Blombos",
      "recordCheck": "Same record; earlier engraved ochre in the same cave [TBV]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/henshilwood-abstract-drawing"
    },
    {
      "slug": "working-page-mythic",
      "title": "Working page: Mythic Consciousness",
      "source": "Michael Haupt's working page, Evolution of Consciousness (Roam)",
      "sourceSlug": null,
      "threshold": "Mythic Consciousness",
      "structure": "Mythic",
      "structureOrder": 3,
      "dateGiven": "about 70,000 years ago",
      "yearsAgo": 70000,
      "basis": "Homo sapiens; language and myth [MS]",
      "recordCheck": "Pigment use about 164,000 years ago at Pinnacle Point (Marean et al. 2007, Nature 449); ochre drawing about 73,000 years ago at Blombos (Henshilwood et al. 2018, Nature 562) [IC]",
      "fit": "later",
      "grade": "[MS]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/working-page-mythic"
    },
    {
      "slug": "briggs-mythical",
      "title": "Roger Briggs: Mythical",
      "source": "Roger Briggs, Emerging World (2021)",
      "sourceSlug": "briggs-2021-emerging-world",
      "threshold": "Mythical",
      "structure": "Mythic",
      "structureOrder": 3,
      "dateGiven": "starting about 60,000 years ago, with the Great Leap",
      "yearsAgo": 60000,
      "basis": "Emerging World, ch. 4, pp. 124, 152: the Great Leap, with new kinds of tools, the dispersal out of Africa and complex spoken language [TBV]",
      "recordCheck": "Pigment use about 164,000 years ago at Pinnacle Point (Marean et al. 2007, Nature 449); ochre drawing about 73,000 years ago at Blombos (Henshilwood et al. 2018, Nature 562) [IC]",
      "fit": "later",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/briggs-mythical"
    },
    {
      "slug": "mithen-cognitive-fluidity",
      "title": "Steven Mithen: cognitive fluidity",
      "source": "Steven Mithen, The Prehistory of the Mind (1996)",
      "sourceSlug": "mithen-1996-prehistory-of-the-mind",
      "threshold": "cognitive fluidity",
      "structure": "Mythic",
      "structureOrder": 3,
      "dateGiven": "about 60,000 to 30,000 years ago",
      "yearsAgo": 60000,
      "basis": "European Upper Palaeolithic record",
      "recordCheck": "Blombos drawing about 73,000 years ago (Henshilwood et al. 2018); Pinnacle Point pigment about 164,000 years ago (Marean et al. 2007) [IC]",
      "fit": "later",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/mithen-cognitive-fluidity"
    },
    {
      "slug": "lewis-williams-image-making",
      "title": "David Lewis-Williams: higher-order consciousness and image-making",
      "source": "David Lewis-Williams, The Mind in the Cave (2002)",
      "sourceSlug": "lewis-williams-2002-mind-in-the-cave",
      "threshold": "higher-order consciousness and image-making",
      "structure": "Mythic",
      "structureOrder": 3,
      "dateGiven": "Upper Palaeolithic, about 40,000 years ago in Europe [TBV]",
      "yearsAgo": 40000,
      "basis": "Western European cave art",
      "recordCheck": "Blombos drawing about 73,000 years ago (Henshilwood et al. 2018) [IC]",
      "fit": "later",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/lewis-williams-image-making"
    },
    {
      "slug": "met-page-mythic",
      "title": "MET page: Mythic",
      "source": "Major Evolutionary Transitions (wiki concept page)",
      "sourceSlug": null,
      "threshold": "Mythic",
      "structure": "Mythic",
      "structureOrder": 3,
      "dateGiven": "the great civilisations of antiquity (Egypt, Sumer, Babylon)",
      "yearsAgo": 5000,
      "basis": "Culture-dominant empires organise the ascent of the curve [MS]",
      "recordCheck": "Symbolic behaviour from about 164,000 years ago (Marean et al. 2007) [IC]; first states in the late fourth millennium BCE [TBV]",
      "fit": "later",
      "grade": "[MS]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/met-page-mythic"
    },
    {
      "slug": "bellah-mimetic-and-mythic-religion",
      "title": "Robert N. Bellah: mimetic and mythic religion",
      "source": "Robert N. Bellah, Religion in Human Evolution (2011)",
      "sourceSlug": "bellah-2011-religion-in-human-evolution",
      "threshold": "mimetic and mythic religion",
      "structure": "Mythic",
      "structureOrder": 3,
      "dateGiven": "deep time; tribal and archaic religion",
      "yearsAgo": null,
      "basis": "Donald; ethnography",
      "recordCheck": "Pinnacle Point and Blombos symbolic record",
      "fit": "not-comparable",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/bellah-mimetic-and-mythic-religion"
    },
    {
      "slug": "maynard-smith-szathmary-language",
      "title": "Maynard Smith and Szathmáry: human societies with language",
      "source": "Maynard Smith and Szathmáry, The Major Transitions in Evolution (1995)",
      "sourceSlug": "maynard-smith-szathmary-1995-major-transitions",
      "threshold": "human societies with language",
      "structure": "Mythic",
      "structureOrder": 3,
      "dateGiven": "not dated",
      "yearsAgo": null,
      "basis": "Information transmission",
      "recordCheck": "No date given",
      "fit": "undated",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/maynard-smith-szathmary-language"
    },
    {
      "slug": "working-page-material",
      "title": "Working page: Material Consciousness",
      "source": "Michael Haupt's working page, Evolution of Consciousness (Roam)",
      "sourceSlug": null,
      "threshold": "Material Consciousness",
      "structure": "Material",
      "structureOrder": 4,
      "dateGiven": "about 12,000 years ago, with writing from about 3200 BCE",
      "yearsAgo": 12000,
      "basis": "The Neolithic Revolution [MS]",
      "recordCheck": "Early farming in Southwest Asia from about 11,500 years ago [TBV]; Earliest writing in Mesopotamia about 3200 BCE [TBV]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[MS]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/working-page-material"
    },
    {
      "slug": "ong-writing",
      "title": "Walter J. Ong: writing",
      "source": "Walter J. Ong, Orality and Literacy (1982)",
      "sourceSlug": "ong-1982-orality-and-literacy",
      "threshold": "writing",
      "structure": "Material",
      "structureOrder": 4,
      "dateGiven": "script from about 3500 BCE [TBV]",
      "yearsAgo": 5500,
      "basis": "History of writing",
      "recordCheck": "Earliest writing in Mesopotamia about 3200 BCE [TBV]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/ong-writing"
    },
    {
      "slug": "donald-theoretic-culture",
      "title": "Merlin Donald: theoretic culture",
      "source": "Merlin Donald, Origins of the Modern Mind (1991)",
      "sourceSlug": "donald-1991-origins-of-the-modern-mind",
      "threshold": "theoretic culture",
      "structure": "Material",
      "structureOrder": 4,
      "dateGiven": "with writing and external symbolic storage",
      "yearsAgo": 5200,
      "basis": "External memory devices; Greek theoretic thought",
      "recordCheck": "Earliest writing in Mesopotamia about 3200 BCE [TBV]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/donald-theoretic-culture"
    },
    {
      "slug": "briggs-mental-material",
      "title": "Roger Briggs: Material",
      "source": "Roger Briggs, Emerging World (2021)",
      "sourceSlug": "briggs-2021-emerging-world",
      "threshold": "Material",
      "structure": "Material",
      "structureOrder": 4,
      "dateGiven": "about 5,000 years ago, with the first civilisations",
      "yearsAgo": 5000,
      "basis": "Emerging World, ch. 5, p. 166: the Material macro-stage begins with the first civilisations in Persia and Egypt [TBV]",
      "recordCheck": "Earliest writing in Mesopotamia about 3200 BCE [TBV]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/briggs-mental-material"
    },
    {
      "slug": "jaynes-breakdown-of-the-bicameral-mind",
      "title": "Julian Jaynes: breakdown of the bicameral mind",
      "source": "Julian Jaynes, The Origin of Consciousness (1976)",
      "sourceSlug": "jaynes-1976-origin-of-consciousness",
      "threshold": "breakdown of the bicameral mind",
      "structure": "Material",
      "structureOrder": 4,
      "dateGiven": "late second millennium BCE [TBV]",
      "yearsAgo": 3200,
      "basis": "Texts such as the Iliad and the Old Testament; Bronze Age upheaval",
      "recordCheck": "Late Bronze Age disruptions in the eastern Mediterranean around 1200 BCE [TBV]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/jaynes-breakdown-of-the-bicameral-mind"
    },
    {
      "slug": "gebser-mental-structure",
      "title": "Jean Gebser: mental structure",
      "source": "Jean Gebser, The Ever-Present Origin",
      "sourceSlug": "gebser-ever-present-origin",
      "threshold": "mental structure",
      "structure": "Material",
      "structureOrder": 4,
      "dateGiven": "first millennium BCE [TBV]",
      "yearsAgo": 3000,
      "basis": "Greek philosophy and perspectival art",
      "recordCheck": "Written records of the first millennium BCE [TBV]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/gebser-mental-structure"
    },
    {
      "slug": "bellah-theoretic-culture",
      "title": "Robert N. Bellah: theoretic culture in the Axial Age",
      "source": "Robert N. Bellah, Religion in Human Evolution (2011)",
      "sourceSlug": "bellah-2011-religion-in-human-evolution",
      "threshold": "theoretic culture in the Axial Age",
      "structure": "Material",
      "structureOrder": 4,
      "dateGiven": "first millennium BCE",
      "yearsAgo": 2800,
      "basis": "Donald's stages; Axial texts",
      "recordCheck": "Documentary record [TBV]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/bellah-theoretic-culture"
    },
    {
      "slug": "jaspers-axial-age",
      "title": "Karl Jaspers: Axial Age",
      "source": "Karl Jaspers, The Origin and Goal of History (1949)",
      "sourceSlug": "jaspers-1949-origin-and-goal-of-history",
      "threshold": "Axial Age",
      "structure": "Material",
      "structureOrder": 4,
      "dateGiven": "about 800 to 200 BCE",
      "yearsAgo": 2800,
      "basis": "Texts of thinkers in China, India, Iran, Israel and Greece",
      "recordCheck": "Documentary record of first-millennium BCE texts; later scholars question the synchrony [TBV]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/jaspers-axial-age"
    },
    {
      "slug": "gebser-perspectival-era",
      "title": "Jean Gebser: perspectival era of the mental structure",
      "source": "Jean Gebser, The Ever-Present Origin",
      "sourceSlug": "gebser-ever-present-origin",
      "threshold": "perspectival era of the mental structure",
      "structure": "Material",
      "structureOrder": 4,
      "dateGiven": "from the Renaissance [TBV]",
      "yearsAgo": 600,
      "basis": "Linear perspective in art",
      "recordCheck": "Documentary record of Renaissance painting [TBV]",
      "fit": "consistent",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/gebser-perspectival-era"
    },
    {
      "slug": "met-page-material",
      "title": "MET page: Material",
      "source": "Major Evolutionary Transitions (wiki concept page)",
      "sourceSlug": null,
      "threshold": "Material",
      "structure": "Material",
      "structureOrder": 4,
      "dateGiven": "the scientific revolution; the last several centuries",
      "yearsAgo": 450,
      "basis": "Economy-dominant empires; science, rights and markets [MS]",
      "recordCheck": "Earliest writing in Mesopotamia about 3200 BCE [TBV]; Early farming in Southwest Asia from about 11,500 years ago [TBV]",
      "fit": "later",
      "grade": "[MS]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/met-page-material"
    },
    {
      "slug": "graeber-wengrow-no-stage-sequence",
      "title": "Graeber and Wengrow: no stage sequence of social forms",
      "source": "Graeber and Wengrow, The Dawn of Everything (2021)",
      "sourceSlug": "graeber-wengrow-2021-dawn-of-everything",
      "threshold": "no stage sequence of social forms",
      "structure": "Material",
      "structureOrder": 4,
      "dateGiven": "none",
      "yearsAgo": null,
      "basis": "Archaeology of early towns and seasonal societies",
      "recordCheck": "Large early settlements without clear hierarchy [TBV]",
      "fit": "not-comparable",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/graeber-wengrow-no-stage-sequence"
    },
    {
      "slug": "gebser-integral-structure",
      "title": "Jean Gebser: integral (aperspectival) structure",
      "source": "Jean Gebser, The Ever-Present Origin",
      "sourceSlug": "gebser-ever-present-origin",
      "threshold": "integral (aperspectival) structure",
      "structure": "Mycelial",
      "structureOrder": 5,
      "dateGiven": "twentieth century",
      "yearsAgo": 100,
      "basis": "Modern art, physics and literature",
      "recordCheck": "No dated marker",
      "fit": "not-comparable",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/gebser-integral-structure"
    },
    {
      "slug": "working-page-mycelial",
      "title": "Working page: Mycelial Consciousness",
      "source": "Michael Haupt's working page, Evolution of Consciousness (Roam)",
      "sourceSlug": null,
      "threshold": "Mycelial Consciousness",
      "structure": "Mycelial",
      "structureOrder": 5,
      "dateGiven": "over about the last sixty years",
      "yearsAgo": 60,
      "basis": "Digital technology; collective, collaborative wisdom [MS]",
      "recordCheck": "No dated archaeological marker; no measured population-level study",
      "fit": "not-comparable",
      "grade": "[MS]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/working-page-mycelial"
    },
    {
      "slug": "beck-cowan-second-tier",
      "title": "Beck and Cowan: second tier",
      "source": "Beck and Cowan, Spiral Dynamics (1996)",
      "sourceSlug": "beck-cowan-spiral-dynamics",
      "threshold": "second tier",
      "structure": "Mycelial",
      "structureOrder": 5,
      "dateGiven": "late twentieth century [TBV]",
      "yearsAgo": 50,
      "basis": "Graves's momentous leap",
      "recordCheck": "No dated marker",
      "fit": "not-comparable",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/beck-cowan-second-tier"
    },
    {
      "slug": "briggs-integral-emerging",
      "title": "Roger Briggs: Planetary",
      "source": "Roger Briggs, Emerging World (2021)",
      "sourceSlug": "briggs-2021-emerging-world",
      "threshold": "Planetary",
      "structure": "Mycelial",
      "structureOrder": 5,
      "dateGiven": "now",
      "yearsAgo": 0,
      "basis": "Emerging World, ch. 5, p. 166: Planetary consciousness, after Gebser's Integral, is emerging now [TBV]",
      "recordCheck": "No dated marker",
      "fit": "not-comparable",
      "grade": "[TBV]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/briggs-integral-emerging"
    },
    {
      "slug": "teilhard-noosphere",
      "title": "Pierre Teilhard de Chardin: noosphere",
      "source": "Pierre Teilhard de Chardin, The Phenomenon of Man (1955)",
      "sourceSlug": "teilhard-1955-the-phenomenon-of-man",
      "threshold": "noosphere",
      "structure": "Mycelial",
      "structureOrder": 5,
      "dateGiven": "unfolding in the present age",
      "yearsAgo": 0,
      "basis": "Theology and palaeontology",
      "recordCheck": "No dated marker",
      "fit": "not-comparable",
      "grade": "[IC]",
      "url": "https://wiki.bioconomy.earth/research/evolution-of-consciousness/dates/teilhard-noosphere"
    }
  ]
}
